Podcast archive Unofficial · Luke Leaman appearances
Menu
← The Muscle Nerds: Muscle Building Principles, Changing Body Composition And Sacrifices

Chapter 8 · Rebuild Health and Fitness Podcast

Muscle Building Principles and Nutrient Timing

May 09, 2022

Yeah. This goes on to my next topic. Perfect segue. So building muscle, then basic sort of principles that we know, but I obviously want to hear some of the stuff from you if there is anything else that you've seen through experience. Obviously, one of them is maybe muscle protein synthesis, maybe looking at just nutrient timing. I suppose that's where the nutrient timing myth comes in with more meals. And something that I see is with our morning trainers. So people train pretty hard here, and they'll come in at 5am and they'll smash a session, and then they'll fast till like midday. I'm like, probably not ideal time to fast, right?

Right.

But then there's this anabolic window that we used to believe in probably a little bit more than what we do. You know, before I would even finish my last set, I'm like supping a protein shake down. People, I think the research is like one to three hours, but I'll still have something within that first hour, like

One to three minutes a day.

Yeah, desperately. Yeah.

But okay, so here's kind of my take on that. All right, so is there a magic window? Yes. Is it larger than we traditionally thought? Yes. But there's a big window of putting carbs in the right places and turning carbs in the right things and also shuttling amino acids in the right places, and basically cutting down on catabolic rates and increasing muscle protein synthesis. Now, how much does that matter? It depends on your viewpoint. For me, if I'm training four sessions a week, let's say four sessions a week, and let's say 10 years, right, that I'm dedicating to this, and I delay my feeding window by two hours, I've just lost out on like 14,000 something hours of recovery. When you look at it like that, if you take a big view on it and not try to micromanage it, those little things may add up, especially if somebody's natural and they're not taking any gear. And it's the easiest fucking thing you could ever possibly do is to just drink a protein shake after your workout. Like that, all you have to do is put powder in a bottle, put water in there, shake it up, and drink it. Like, I don't even know why people argue about that anymore. I think they're just doing it just to be contradictory. You know? And you've got people saying, "Oh, it doesn't matter, protein timing doesn't matter, you just need to get all your protein in a day. Well, looking at the research, it does matter, especially if it's hypertrophy, because you're going through the ebb and flow of muscle protein synthesis and breakdown. And so, you know, you have your protein shake. Let's say you train. Training is causing muscle protein breakdown, but it also stimulates a muscle protein synthetic response after it. And then you have a little bit of carbohydrate, a little bit of protein. That's going to amplify that. In a few hours, that's going to go back into muscle protein breakdown. Probably a good idea to have another, at least some protein if you're serious about gaining muscle really fast and being really consistent with it. You probably do want more meals.

Especially if you're eating a lot of calories anyways, because you probably want to divvy up that energy over more frequent feedings.

Yeah, everyone should be getting at least four feedings.

I think so.

Breakfast, lunch, dinner, and like you said, that additional shake.

What about refractory periods? Because I think back in the day, I think a couple of things I heard was like 2.5 hours, like minimum 2.5 hours, probably putting it towards three. But now people are like, oh, just keep eating protein. Because like sucking amino acids, for example, it's like if you need that refractory period of three hours, but in between every protein feed-in you're sucking on amino acids or BCAAs, would that cause an effect? If anything, you would say you'd be losing gains, wouldn't you?

I don't know. I don't know because sometimes experience shows you different things than what you see in the literature. Like, I remember, I cannot remember who told me about this, but somebody was talking about like amino acid pulses, and I think it might have been me talking to Dr. James LaValle about it, and so I decided to try it. And so I started drinking lots of essential

amino acids between meals. And then one day, this is when I was still one of the head coaches at Polican Group, and I walked in and one of the girls that I worked with, she goes, "You look really big." And I'd only been doing this for like a week. And I walked in, I was like, "I feel big. I do."

You're like, "Thanks."

And I'm walking.

I can't believe you didn't marry her.

I'm walking through the gym and I'm like, "Fuck, I'm puffed."

Why am I so puffed? I went and got on the scale. I'd put on like 12 pounds in a week. Yeah. Through doing that protein pulse, but a lot of it was just bloated water shit. Yeah. And I was really uncomfortable. I didn't feel good. And my food, I didn't feel like my food was being processed that well. And so I stopped doing that. But I think for somebody who might be really ectomorphic and really skinny and has a hard time putting on weight, that might be a good strategy for them. They probably have a hard time building muscle anyways. But somebody who's more mesomorphic and endomorphic, it's probably not a great strategy for them. But yeah, for me it's just eat foods. Just eat your food and eat often. But it depends too, if you're looking at muscle building versus weight loss. I like intermittent time-restricted eating for fat loss just because I find for most people, if they can get through that eating, that non-eating window, that fasting window, and not have issues like reactive hypoglycemia or hypoglycemia, and they can get through that, they tend to feel more satisfied when they can eat two or three meals in, say, a six or eight hour window because their meals are a lot bigger, especially when they're getting down to low calories. Somebody who's eating like 1500 calories for a guy, you know, am I going to eat five 300 calorie snacks or do I just save it all up for one or for two or three big meals at the end of the day?

Yeah, I'm not anti-fasting. It's something I'll use. It just depends on when they train. That's sort of the big one for me. If they train in the morning, then I'm just, I am anti-fasting. I just don't think we should be doing it. So we can make up a time-restricted window in the middle of the day, if you want to call it that, but for PM, yeah, for sure. That's it.

Yeah, I think if you're going to do that and you're going to train in the morning, you probably that's where timing probably makes a big difference. You probably want to maybe have a little bit of something before you train. Maybe even it's just like 15 grams of carbohydrates.

Half a banana or something.

Yeah, half a banana, some or just a little bit of juice, just something to get your blood sugar up a little bit, and then maybe have your protein shake after that, and then go back in your fasting after that if you want to.

Isn't there something around women should, it's more important, I haven't looked at it, it's more important for females to eat pre-training than it is for males? Have you heard anything there?

You've heard about, doesn't, isn't, well, maybe it wasn't you, but I have heard, and again, not looked into, not confirmed, that we aren't as, we have to be a little bit more careful with fasting due to us not having as many androgenic hormones and we don't have that protection from them. Didn't I hear that from you?

I think I've seen Stacey Sims post something about that.

I don't know who that is.

We don't know who that is, Sean.

And this is the problem, like what I've just done twice now is just passing shit on without even looking into it and just like, "I've heard this," and then believing it. So I should probably stop.

Stop the facts.

But I mean, at the end of the day, it's probably a moot point because if you're trying to lose body fat

You're not in a deficit anyway.

What?

Because you're just eating off your body.

Yeah, that's a weird concept I came up with is you're not actually in a deficit unless you're starving to death.

It's just what you consume as a deficit. Your body makes the balance up from your food stores.

You've got exogenous food you're eating now, you can count it, you've got endogenous food that you've eaten before you can process. You're not, if you think about that, you're not actually, if you got all the cofactors, you're not really in a deficit just on paper because your body's going to make that up with the body fat you're trying to get rid of. Now, once you get to the point where you're really lean, now you're in a deficit because now your body's starting to tear itself down from eating muscle and bone or whatever because you're now starving to death, which is, if you want to be a body builder, that's what you're doing.

Yeah, it's taking it to another level.

I was watching Chris Bumstead, when he was getting ready, I think, for the Olympia. And if you want to be a bodybuilder, cool. Go watch some of these bodybuilders when they're a month out, two months out, and look at how haggard they look and how tired and miserable they are. He looked, in the face, he just looked terrible. And he's talking about how he's doing like two hours of cardio a day and eating 1600 calories, and this dude's 105 kilos.

He's a big man.

Yeah, and that's controlled starvation. That's what it takes to win a bodybuilding show these days at the high levels.

Ridiculous, isn't it? The size of them now is just like fascinating. Calorie surplus if we're talking muscle building. How big are we talking?

You don't need a huge calorie surplus.

It's pretty small, right?

That's, you can gain size in a deficit if the deficit

isn't too big and your protein's pumped up. They've made that pretty clear. It's not, again, not the most optimal. You're talking more of a recomp, but people put too much focus on the calories. You need sufficient calories to train. You need sufficient calories to run your body. But you don't need a ton of extra calories to gain muscle unless you just want to get fat too.

Just a big bulk.

Just a big bulk, like these dirty bulks. I mean, what's the point? At some point, you gotta pull that off. So you're basically just spinning your wheels a little bit, like doing the old Lee Priest method.

And there's no huge benefit to having more body fat.

No, not really. Not really. I mean, there might, if you're, let's say you're 5% body fat, there might be getting to 10, 12, 13, 14 is probably going to be better physiologically. But there's no benefit of being 20, 23, 24%. Dr. Darren Willoughby talked about this at Swiss in 2015. He did a lecture, Biochemistry of Hypertrophy and Fat Loss, and he said, "Look, calories are not your driver for gaining muscle. Protein is."

Nitration, yeah.

Lifting and protein. He goes, "You don't need that many calories above maintenance. You could even eat at maintenance if your protein's high enough and you're training hard and you're recovering well, you're going to get big. That's the fact. If you start adding 1,000 calories extra, you're going to get big, but it's not going to be the bigness you're looking for.

Obviously, we've got things like sleep and hydration we don't think we need to touch on too much. Hopefully everyone knows the importance of that by now. We've done some others. What about mind-muscle connection?

For me, it's super important. Super important. A lot of that has to go with understanding technique and having more intent. I think it's more important for beginners than people who are more advanced. If you're advanced and you need more mind-muscle connection, you're still a beginner. That's where I think like Kassam and some of the N1 stuff, getting in those certain positions and being very intentional about how you're lifting and really focusing on a very certain specific area is really good in the first early stages of your training. Once you become more advanced, some of that stuff I like if you have holes in your physique, but at the time where you get becoming really advanced and elite level, anything you do is going to work. You just, you've basically laid down the foundation of if I bench and keep getting strong, everything's gonna get bigger. Right? So, if a lot of people focus more on getting stronger and really basic fundamental stuff, they would have a lot better physique. It'd be more well-rounded.

Because was it Generation Iron a few years ago with the bodybuilders, that guy that was always in the lab, like working with EPs, and there was that other guy that rode horses and just fucking picked up shit, just like threw shit around.

And it was always the battle between those two, old school v new school.

It's with everything though, like even when we were talking about the pend- like when you're talking about how now people are saying, you know, you should be able to lose fat off 3,000 calories, like the pendulum always swings from one way to the other. Like the answer is usually somewhere in the middle. It's like a blend of like the perfect balance of everything is where the answer lies.

Yeah. And like with training, the big thing now is move the bar as fast as possible. You always want to explode the bar off. Okay? Because, you know, we want to look at force production. So we want to have, you know, enough mass and we want to accelerate it really quickly. When you look at bodybuilding physique, we know it's undeniable fact that tension creates a hypertrophic response. I'll sometimes tell my clients to slow their concentric down to two seconds. And they go, "Well, I thought we were supposed to explode this off the chest. I'm like, yeah, you can. You could work on faster acceleration, but that reduces your time under tension. So you might need more volume doing that. If you just slow it down and say moderate mass, moderate acceleration, keep the muscle under tension longer, you are reinforcing that mind-muscle connection, and you're also digging deeper into keeping the muscle contracted for a longer period of time. You just don't want to get crazy on that, start doing the old, what's the super slow training where they're doing 10 second concentric and eccentrics. But like if you put a 3010 or a 4010 on somebody's tempo, if you put 4010 it's always going to be 1, 2, 3, 4. And if you put 1, they're going to go 1. No, I want 3 down and squeeze 1 up. I don't want you to throw the bar off your body. I want you to squeeze the bar up. Because anytime you start accelerating the bar quickly, you're inherently going to be using a lot of stuff you're not intending to use. So for bodybuilding, if we're looking at, we're using targeted training, we want to target the muscles that we're trying to target, not just move through movement-centric only stuff. We need muscle-centric stuff, which means you need to be dialed in, focused. You might have to slow down the tempo a little bit to dig into the areas you want to dig into.

Do you find that, like, big differences when you're working out training volumes, whether this be for like male and female athletes, whether they're pushing for strength or just hypertrophy, that you have to take a different approach between like either sex? Because I know like with elite CrossFit athletes, for example, the top female athletes tend to be able to produce higher reps, more reps at higher percentages of their lifts, whereas males have a, like, once they hit their 90% of anything, they're only hitting like two, three reps, but there is tends to be a bit of a bigger jump between their 1RM, whereas the top female athletes can do like sets of 10 at 90%, but then they've only got that little bit of a jump between their 1RM.

Yeah, so if you look back, what we've kind of experienced has showed us that women tend to not, they tend to be more neurologically inefficient than men, which probably comes to some of those strength discrepancies. So men tend to do less reps at a higher percentage than women. Women also tend to buffer things better. So women tend to be pound for pound a little bit better at endurance stuff, but then men can, a lot of times men can override that with better running economy by just simply being stronger, having a better power to weight ratio. So sometimes we'll may skew the rep ranges a little bit. So if I give a guy a 5x5, I might give a girl a 5x7 instead to kind of accommodate that difference. But training age also, advancement in training also neutralizes some of that. So when you start getting into the higher training age, that gap starts to shorten itself down. It's not as broad as it used to be. But you're also a product of how you train. So if you're a woman and you train with higher rep schemes because of that offset, you get better performance the way you train it. So like I'll give you an example. When I was still a competitive powerlifter, I had a buddy of mine who could bench 405 about 12 to 15 times, but he couldn't do 425 once. And he told me that. I was like, "No way, bullshit." I mean, this is like 20 years ago. I'm like, "No way, let's go to the gym." So we put 405 on the bar. I get maybe three or four. He pumps out 15 solid reps. We put 420 on the bar. He lowers it down, completely staples his ass. But he only lifted in that 10 to 12 rep range. That's what he constantly did. He never lifted heavy. So that's how his specific training adapted him in a specific way. And it made no sense to me because you look at like one rep max continuum, it doesn't make any sense because 12 reps should be somewhere around like 67 to 70%. So he should have been benching like 500 pounds. Like five, even more, like 560, 570 something. He couldn't do one rep with 15 pounds more than that.

It's true though. He's seen it. I'm thinking about it in my own training now and I've gone through sort of just blocks of hypertrophy around that sort of 8 to 12. And then when I go and do a test or go and test my one, it's nowhere near what I believe it should be. It's fucking way lower. It's really depressing.

Isn't it like though that really dirty muscle fiber makeup test that you know of?

Like the Hatfield test and the Pelican test?

Yeah. Like do your one rep max and put 85%.

Yeah, so the Hatfield I think is 80% and Charles did one that's 85%. So I like Charles's version a little bit better because that extra 5% makes a big difference. But what you basically do is you test your one rep max, rest 10 minutes, and then put 85% on the bar and see how many reps you get. So if you're getting, say, under five, you're going to be more fast twitch and more nervous system dominant. If you're getting between like five to eight, you're a bit mixed. If you're getting more than eight, then you're going to be more slow twitch and probably not as well developed of a nervous system. And I find that to be fairly accurate. I had a lady once, raw beginner. Beginners will always lift. They can't, a beginner can't tap into all of their, a good majority of their high threshold motor units. I think the last, I saw a study a while back that said most people that are beginning strength training can only tap into about 30% of their high threshold motor units. So they're never going to, they're not going to get that much benefit in the initial stages in maximal strength. They're probably better off just lifting in functional hypertrophy, hypertrophy strength endurance. And then once they become more well developed, then going into maximal strength because they can't express maximal strength anyways. So for me, you're almost wasting your time the first year if you're doing singles, doubles, triples, unless it's more specific for something like weightlifting or powerlifting.