Podcast archive Unofficial · Luke Leaman appearances
Menu
← The Muscle Nerds: Muscle Building Principles, Changing Body Composition And Sacrifices

Chapter 6 · Rebuild Health and Fitness Podcast

Body Composition and Recomposition

May 09, 2022

Talking about that, so the next thing I sort of want to talk about is sort of like body recomposition in a way, but more like changing your body composition. If I say body recomposition, a lot of people think losing fat and building muscle at the same time and usually fall into three groups here. It's like, yes, we can do it, no, we can't do it, or two, we can do both but not directly, you know, at the same time.

You absolutely can do both at the same time.

It's not as efficient if you have, let's say you have a lot of weight to lose, doing a slow recomp like that, it's not the most efficient way of doing it. So if I had somebody that came in, and people are always way fatter than they think. Like I have a guy I've trained on and off for years, he was 207 pounds, and he's like, I go, what are we going to do? He came back on for training, he's like, I want 10%. I want to have a six-pack." I'm like, "Okay. You're going to have to lose like 50 pounds, 40 pounds probably." He's like, "No." I'm like, "Yeah. You are." So I put him on a protein-sparing modified fast, very low calories, right? Adjusted his training for it. He lost 12, 13 kilos in 12 weeks. Was it 12? That was faster than that. And he's like, "I'm still fat." I'm like, "I told you, you probably have another 12 kilos to go." And so now he's now knuckled down. Now that we've got that big, we've got half of it off, now we've moved to a slower recomp so we pumped the calories up. So now we're just focused on losing 300 or 400, maybe 500 grams a week. Like, okay, let's take another 24 weeks to get there and we'll go with a recomp. That way you build muscle and grow into that. But it really just depends on what the priority is. If fat loss is a priority, you probably want to not just try to hold on as much muscle tissue as you can. Keep your protein high because that's going to be the biggest factor, and don't train too much because people will start utilizing exercise to burn calories. When you don't have a lot of calories on board, that's a disaster.

So where would you put that protein at this point?

As high as they can get it. I always say, what can you afford, what can you digest, and what do you want? So if you're somebody, if you're Texan and you look protein, I'm gonna put, I'm gonna pump it up. I usually cap it off around like 3, 3 grams per kilo, maybe 3.3.

Yeah, wow.

It's not to me.

I used to eat like 4, 4.4.

I just can't afford it with the fucking meat prices right now. But

A lot of smelly farts going on.

Always. It's always something if it's not the protein

Doesn't matter what I eat, that happens. But yeah, typically I'll put people on around two, probably the most often protein amount is about 2.5 grams per kilo. So we try to keep between that 2.2 to 2.5. But I'm also a big believer in protein leverage diets. So if you need to lose a lot of fat, I still much prefer a low-carb diet, but we have to-- I've stopped calling it a low-carb, I call it a lower-carb diet. So I tend to start off by lowering the carbohydrates quite a bit and keeping the fat and the protein high because that unlocks a lot more protein choices. It makes your food taste better. People tend to digest things a bit slower, so they tend to be happier on that type of diet. But when I say low carb, I'm talking about the traditional low carb. Traditionally in the research, low carb was anything under 40%. Nowadays it's like negative carbs.

Just zero.

Celery.

You can't even look at carbs anymore. It's like, no, if we're, you know, something around like 130 grams of carbs instead of, you don't have to go to keto land for this, and you can still be really, you can be really happy and satiated. You can still have some rice and potatoes and things like that. But then again, it depends on what type of person they are. If they really love carbs, okay, let's take the fat down a little bit. The only non-negotiable for me is I want your protein to be at least 2 to 2.2 grams per kilo.

Yeah, and that's where I suppose it can get a little bit difficult. I suppose if you're talking general pop as well, because you just look at people have these massive protein intakes, but their calories are put on so low and the maths doesn't always make sense, or they just really struggle at that point as well. I'll sort of look at a recomp usually with people that are quite skinny or skinny fat. Yes, that skinny fat, right? And they come in and they're just like, "I'm just not lean enough yet, I just need to keep going." I'm like, "You need to stop for now, right? We need to spend a little bit of time building or you're never going to sort of find."

Yeah, you're like, "Man, you got really shredded bones." You look like a fucking coat hanger. Like, how lean do you what are you getting like what's The Machinist? Is that what you're trying to look like?

Full Christian Bale.

Yeah, like that's not really a great look. So yeah, building the muscle. But a lot of that has to do with doing the right types of training, the programming, doing more hypertrophy-based stuff and keeping your protein high.

Yeah, I've got that to come, big one to come about that. So when would you go a certain way, so sort of like, would you look at a certain body fat percentage in terms of hey let's diet or hey let's build?

Yeah, there's no

Or is it like physiological and psychological too, right?

Yeah, there's really no good numbers. There's some, you can make some assumptions. I usually will say look, I like guys to try to

get somewhere about 15 to 16%, maybe 17% is my upper threshold. So if I can get you down below 15 and then kind of keep you between 15 and 17, and then once you start hitting close to 18, 19, let's pull it back down. For women, we usually add about 5 or 6% on top of that. So for women, we look at, you know, somewhere around maybe 24 to 27. And then if they want to stay lean, then we might take them down a little bit closer to 21, 22 and kind of stay in that area. But this is, I'm also talking about true body fat percentage, not people's weird idea what true body fat percentage is, because 15% is leaner than you think it is. And a lot of guys who think they're 15%, they're like 28%. A lot of girls who think they're 16%, they're more like 32%.

Because their scale told them what percentage. That's it.

At home scales. You're a big fan, well you historically have been a big fan of getting them leaner first and then going on muscle because isn't it easier to put on muscle if you're not as

Yeah, there's a lot of arguments about that, about like, what's the P ratio? And I just, from experience, what I see is the fatter you get, the more insulin resistant you get, the harder it is to put on muscle and the easier it is to put on fat. If you think about, if you think about what happens when we age, people naturally get more insulin resistant. They also have to eat more protein because they don't have an anabolic response. They become anabolically resistant. For me, a lot of the times when I see people, like guys getting close to 20%, they're bulking but they're not putting on the type of bulk they're looking for. And I'm convinced that there's an anabolic resistance issue because the insulin receptor is not working that well. And people argue about this, but you know, I don't think the data is conclusive. You see people talk about, well, look at sumo wrestlers, they're really fat and they have lots of muscle. I'm like, yeah, but

I mean, they're the people that we want to be looking for for advice now.

Well, and it's like, and they'll say like, well, what about American NFL linemen? I'm like, okay, you can't take the top 0.001% of natural freaks and And, you know, Russian

creatine-supported

freaks. You can't look at them and then look at a gen pop person and go, that's the same. Because growing up in Texas, I had to play against some of these guys who went to play pro ball, and they were like manchildren at like 14. Guys that are like 280 pounds and 6 foot 5, and they're 14, and they've had a beard for like, since they were 8. You can't look at that and make assumptions on whether this stuff is real or not. You have to look at normal people.

Yeah, plus they're going to be motivated easier, right? If you get someone a little bit leaner to start, and every like one pound of muscle mass they build, they're going to just see it a little bit more.

They'll see it, yeah.

Yeah, you got to look at that too. Yeah, so if you are trying to build muscle and you're already a little bit rotund, you're not gonna look better. You're gonna be getting bigger and stronger, but you're gonna be looking worse. You're probably better off getting to a certain amount of leanness, at least like 15%. I think that's reasonable. That's not that hard to get to. And then try to put on, and when you start to look a little sloppy, that's easy to clean up in a few weeks. But you'll get guys that, you know, you look really good in clothes and you take your shirt off, you look like a fucking melted candle. Like you have to look at it like that, but then you go the other way. I was talking to one of my clients about this. He's jacked as fuck and he's like, "I'm so skinny, I'm 95 kilos." He's got full-on abs, giant legs. He's like, "Ah." I'm like, "Yeah, but you only look skinny in clothes." He goes, "Yeah, but I'm training out at Pro Raw and there's all these monsters." I'm like, "Yeah, but you also they're also like waiting for it to have a heart attack."

Yeah, yeah.

And they're all fucked up and they're all joint issues and all this stuff. And part of the reason why we took him down from like 105, we took him down from 105 to like 87 and then I put him, built him back up to 95 is because he was having a bunch of joint issues. Like, well, we're going to fix this a lot easier if we get you tidy your physique up a little bit and work on fixing these things, and then we can start going back the other way, but not to the point where you get overly fat.

Was that pro or was that powerlifting? Yeah.

I was just going to say, you've spoken about ideal body fat percentages a few times, which will sort of dictate your decision about your approach to things. What's your preferred method of working that out? Do you recommend DEXA scans or just weigh measure?

That's I like to go to multiple different components. Because I've been in the physique side of things pretty much my whole life, I like to use pictures, number one. I like to use circumference measures. I like the Navy body fat test because all you need is a $10 tape and you can get a really good assessment on that. So you can look at that and say, well

Also, I've never even heard of that.

So the

American military, a lot of the different branches that were trying to figure out how to work out body composition in something that was easy to do and didn't take a lot of technical skill or cost. So they did a bunch of research on circumference measures and versus your height and your weight and all that. And then they weighted against hydrostatic dunking, right? And they found it's pretty damn accurate if you do it correctly. It's got about as inaccurate as a DEXA scan, which is 3 to 5% up and down. So if you get that and maybe you do do a DEXA scan, maybe you do do skinfolds, in body, whatever you use, and then you just keep using that same method, look at the pictures and say, okay, what is my percentage? How do I look at that percentage? Okay, that gives me a good reference point. When I start looking really good, what does that method show me at now? Because there's no body fat method that's really good. They're all prone to error. And different body types will hold things differently. So even if you look at something like a DEXA or you look at an InBody, your fat cells aren't just fat. There's lean, there's fat-free mass in the fat cells too. So you could have people with big, larger fat cells, but they test leaner than they actually really are because you're measuring fat-free mass inside of the fat cell. If you have somebody with a smaller fat cell, it might be more fat in the fat cell and less fat-free mass. They may actually click off fatter even though they look really lean. So that's why it's really hard.

There's also different prices for DEXA scans, right? Not every single one of them is the gold standard, right?

And DEXAs are all different. So when COVID first hit and I stopped traveling, I was like, okay, we live out where, you know, you get Uber Eats. There's a few really nice places, but most of them aren't that great. And you can only have so many, so much Uber Eats of the same restaurant. So we're like, screw it, I'm just going to pull out the air fryer and I'm gonna get lean again." And I got ridiculously lean. So I went and did a DEXA scan. I was 6.75% on the DEXA. I was probably more like 9.5% to 10%. Navy Body Fat had me at like 9%, something like that. Skinfolds had me at like 11%. So they're all quite a bit different. Earlier this year, I got even leaner. I went to a different DEXA scan. It had me at 8.8. So even DEXA scans aren't the same between them. Some models are better and some of the programming is better than others. But I would say that DEXA scan that I did in Red Cliff was actually more accurate than the place I went to in Brisbane that that's all they do are scans. Like the margin for error was much smaller with the medical place I went to in Red Cliff.

Should we go on to, like, let's talk about building muscle a little bit.

But at the end of the day, the body fat percentage doesn't really matter. What matters is do you like the way you look and feel, right? Because my buddy Nick Daniels said it best to me one time. He goes, "You're only as lean as your fattest spot." I'm like, "Okay, there you go."

God damn it.

It's my back, but I can't see my back.

So it doesn't matter. Out of sight, out of mind.

That's it.

Mine's my dick.

It's your fittest.

Actually, because I used to when I was teaching, I started talking about getting people dick skin lean and that kind of became a thing with our students. And one day I just decided, I wonder what dick skin lean is. So I measured it. It's 2.8 millimeters.

What dick skin?

Dick skin is, yeah.

I've never measured it. I used to know it on a foxtail remote. Sorry, sorry.

Bro.

That's kind of a metric. Can you cover your cell phone? If you do, you're doing all right.

You know these iPhone Max Pros now? Yeah, the mini or the?

Yeah, no, the Yeah. The big one.

The iPhone 3.

You're gonna ask somebody with those Nokia flip phones, they're not gonna flip it out, they're gonna go, "I'm good."