Podcast archive Unofficial · Luke Leaman appearances
Menu
← The Muscle Nerds: Muscle Building Principles, Changing Body Composition And Sacrifices

Chapter 5 · Rebuild Health and Fitness Podcast

Psychological Aspects of Dieting

May 09, 2022

A lot of the complication around diet comes from the fact that every single person has some type of psychological or emotion tied to food, whether that's like enjoyment, pleasure, guilt, it's socializing, it's, you know, like it's to try and take a such an emotive topic and make it so black and white and non-emotive, it's just it's like almost impossible. So you really have to work with the person that's in front of you and you find that thing that works for them, that doesn't just mess them up.

And this is not it's like we always say a good relationship with food is being able to say yes and no to it. So you try and give everyone like some sort of food freedom maybe at the beginning, like, you know, never feel guilty when you eat food, but then they go totally the other way. I have everything. I'm like, well no, you should be able to say no as well. And that should be fine, but now that's looked upon as like-

And you don't want-

Restrictive. It's not.

You also don't want to instill fear around food into your wine either. So it's a really fine line, like it's a really delicate dance. But I remember, I can't remember who it was. It was one of the figures in the industry, like the guy who used to train Gary Vee.

Syed? Oh, Jordan Syed.

Syed.

One thing he put out I really liked, he says progress for one person might be not eating the cake. Progress for another person might be eating the cake and not feeling guilty about it. Like, so it's so vastly different for everyone and I really liked that actually and I was like, that's like nail on the head.

Yeah, it's very true because we got like, you know, I've got a client now who is feeling really guilty about wanting to diet in an office environment where there's food everywhere, always bringing out sweets and let's go out for lunch and all that kind of stuff and she's like trying to be the one who says no and then the other people there almost like diet shame like oh you know just have it you can have it.

Oh yeah 100% I used to eat it all the time. I used to work in an office environment that was like very a feeding environment like we had like a whole breakfast bar that was for free, always lunches, always morning teas, people bringing in cupcakes. Yeah and anytime you turn them down, I always used to get, "Well you might get hit by a bus the next day, like what are you being, this is ridiculous." And I was like, "Yeah, but-"

What are the odds?

I think if I get hit by a bus, my last thought's not going to be like, "I wish I'd eaten that cupcake."

If I keep eating these cupcakes and gain 30 kilos, I'm more likely to get hit by that bus because I can't get out of the way.

Can't move. But a lot of people bring in cupcakes or cakes to offices because they don't want to feel alone in what they're doing. So they share it with other people and believe it's okay.

But the diet shame is real. Like, I spent one year in an office and it was one of the worst years of my life. And I had just come off of a contest, a physique show. So I was like 7.5% body fat. I walk in, everybody's like, "Ooh, the fitness dudes." So they're all asking. The first, here's the novelty, the first few weeks everyone wants advice and stupid me, I'm like, "Okay, I'll help you." By about the third month, I'd be sitting at my desk, typing on my computer. I'd turn to ask somebody a question, they'd be deep-throating a slice of pizza. They'd stop and look at me and go, "Don't judge me!" I'm like, "I don't give a shit." I don't care that you eat the pizza.

Jesus.

This is really interesting because I had this conversation this week about, just say there's some clients, they're in a certain place, right? And we very rarely actually talk about the food that they've eaten. But yet they constantly, I don't know what it's from, they constantly are worried that I'm going to judge them on the food that they're eating, even though they have no evidence that that is ever going to be

Yeah, people come to it. I mean, there's a lot of preconceived notions about what trainers and nutritionists and stuff are like, right? And that's one of them. Is that it's just like shame. I mean, I think that would be I don't know if that would be a social media thing.

I mean, it must have been shaped by some experience they've had in the past, because there's some trainers who are like that when they're going into that sort of challenge mentality. What the fuck, you're meant to stick to this.

Yeah. Well, it's that whole boot camp mentality, right? Like that drill sergeant type one, I guess. I don't know.

Some coaches are just dicks.

Dicks, yeah.

See, I go the opposite way. If my clients go, "Man, I'm really sorry I missed these sessions and I ate a little bit too much, that's why you don't see anything logged on Saturday," I just tell them straight up, "I don't give a shit if you do this or not. That's my job is to tell you what to do, tell you how to get there. It's not my job to slap a donut out of your hand. So you just that's fine. You just delayed the process, but it doesn't affect me either way. If I want you to get your results, that's what you're paying me for, but I'm doing my job. If you're not going to do your side of it, then that's on you. I don't care. Like, don't think I'm going to shame you. I would actually rather you do your best to try to track the binges, which sometimes they do, sometimes they don't. But if you track the binge, I can try to figure out a solution. But if you don't track the binge, I have no idea what to do.

That's a really good point, right? Because everyone likes tracking when they're eating wonderfully. Then they don't track and it's just like If you just did it the opposite way around, it would be a lot easier.

They'll just bury their head in the sand because they'll just think like ignoring it means that the effects won't be as

They'll say, "I didn't know how to track this because it's not chronometer." Just do your best. Like tracking something and having some close to accuracy is better than tracking nothing and having zero accuracy.

I couldn't agree more. I would say I'd rather see 10,000 calories in there a day than no calories in there. Because at least I know.

Yeah. Like Luke says, you can come up with a strategy then because there's a strategy you do for people who binge. You just jack their calories right up.

Yeah, I jack their calories up until they stop binging and then they're always like, "Oh my, no, I can't eat 3,000 calories. I'm supposed to be eating 1200." I'm like, "You're already eating that. You might as well fill it up with good food." Get rid of the binging and the guilt.

Consciously eat it, yeah.

And almost every time they end up losing weight on double or almost triple the calories because at least now they're eating good food, positive stimulation food instead of eating a bunch of shit and feeling guilty about it.

Yeah, that's right. I think getting people to eat up, you're all right. Like, you need to eat these calories. So say, give someone 2400 and they're eating to 18. I'm like, no, get to 24. I don't care what you've got to fill it with. Get to 24. Like, I just not get to 24. Guess what? Yeah, they tend to stop overeating, right? Or reaching for the foods that they usually reach for because they're just thin.

You get crazy shit too where, you know, everybody's anti-processed foods.

look, if you can have some processed food, you're gonna be fine. It's not gonna kill you. Like, I need you to get this in. I had one guy a couple of weeks ago, I told him to eat white rice. He goes, "Oh, I don't eat white rice because it's processed." Are you fucking serious? Eat gross-ass brown rice if you want. Yeah. I mean, the

It's fucking true.

Like, the whole process of eating is processing your food. If you're eating beef mince, it's already been processed. If you're chewing and masticating your food, you're processing it. So, you know, obviously we want to try to get people to eat as much unprocessed foods and natural whole foods as possible, because we do know that's more nutritious, but you can have some of this other stuff as well, especially if you need to fill in your calories, because I was trying to get him to have protein powder to get his protein up, and he goes, "I don't want to do that. It's processed. What else can I eat?" I'm like, "Well, just eat more meat."

Just go and kill a deer and just gnaw on it.

Put your fucking loincloth on and go out in the country and murder your animal and do it that way if you want it so totally paleo.

But there's I'll go.

No, go on.

I was just going to say there's always a really fine line between it going out of our pay grade with dealing. Like when I was talking about there's just so much psychological attachment to food and it's so different for everybody that there is a point where you're like, either probably shouldn't diet or you need to go and talk to someone about like

Yeah, I think that's a fine conversation to have and they usually respect you for it. I think

Not many people act on it though.

You can't help everyone.

No.

Open my drawer. Which top one? Don't open that one. The dildos are in that one. Is there a lolly? So I'll always put like, I always say when I've got nutrition stuff, I'm like, you know, I always look high food, low energy, low energy, high nutrient or whatever it is, and everything's just on a scale. I'm like, everything's fine. I always say if I've got an apple or I've got some Alan's lollies, I'm going to go and train, what am I going to eat? And everyone's like, the apple. I was like, fuck no, no one wants a fucking apple. I'm about to go and train. Give me some You know what I mean? Give me some lollies. So everything has its place. Just have that understanding.

Well, I had a client years ago. She was dealing with a bunch of injuries, and she played Gaelic football and also AFL at a high level, plus her training, plus she commuted on her bike to work and back. She was dealing, she had gone to a different trainer, training company, and they had her on like 1500 calories, and she was probably training 24 hours a week between all of that stuff. And she had all these injuries, and she had seen five or six other therapists to figure out what was going on. They all told her that it was the same problem. They all gave her the same rehab exercise. It wasn't working. So she flew up from Melbourne to see me and I went, "Look, I'm just going to tell you, like all these people, I mean, you've seen Andrew Locke, like you've seen all these other people. They're all right. Like I'm going to tell you the same thing they did. So let's figure out if it's something different." And I found out she needed like 33, 3400 calories. She was eating like 1500. And then she would go on these massive sugar binges where she's almost snorting sugar, you know? And so that was one of the people that I said, "Look, we're going to pump your calories up to like 33, 3400. Let's pump it up close to maintenance." She was terrified. Like, "Look, the reason you're not healing is because you don't have enough energy on board. So let's get the energy on board." She did. She lost something like some ridiculous amount, like three kilos in a week, just adding more food. And all of her injuries went away and she started smashing it in her competitions. But this is how fucked her mentality was because it's how she was programmed training with these other people for four years. She showed up for a game and didn't have any carbohydrates or any. I said, "You need to take some carbs with you before you play." She goes, "I couldn't get any. I don't know what to do." I go, "What do you have around you?" "I've got there's a servo." I'm like, "Go in there, buy a bag of Skittles. Do you like Skittles?" "Yeah." Eats a family pack of Skittles, fucking crushes the game. Crushes the game. They name her captain of the team. And then the next Sunday when she goes to play, she goes, "What do I do for carbs?" I go, "Well, Skittles worked really well last week, so why don't we just eat more Skittles?" She goes, "But what about red dye number 40?" What about what? I'm like, "What?" She goes, "Well, they told me at the other place." I'm like, "Just eat the fucking Skittles, man."

Seriously. That's crazy.

But there's a difference between like sports nutrition too and just like nutrition for fat loss as well. Like that's kind of where it becomes a lot more nuanced when you've got sports nutrition.

And difference between physique.

Yeah, yeah.

You know, but you, most people are getting information from bodybuilders and if you're training, like that may or may not work for Jim Pop and it definitely, bodybuilding nutrition should never be used with a performance athlete. Unless you want them to not perform well.