Podcast archive Unofficial · Luke Leaman appearances
Menu
← Special Guest Feature | The Muscle Nerd Himself - Luke Leaman!

Chapter 9 · The Matter Mentality Podcast

Psychological Challenges of Dieting

March 14, 2025

understand it a little bit more because in a lot of times, these two extremes of the continuum, you'll see very similar pathologies for different reasons, right? So for example, leptin is a good one because a lot of, well, hopefully a lot of coaches understand this concept, that leptin being a global appetite suppressant. So back in the day, it was in the 90s when they figured out what leptin did and they thought, oh, we had this is how we're going to get solve the obesity epidemic. We're just going to inject fat people with leptin and they won't want to eat. So they did that and nothing happened. And then they figured out fat people have super physiological levels of leptin, so the receptors are desensitized. So leptin is never going to fix things. So if you think about people who are grossly obese, like if you go to Vegas and you go to a buffet, you'll see these guys. They can't, they need three seats to sit down and they've got 25 plates stacked at the buffet. They don't have good appetite signaling, so no matter how much they eat, it never touches the side, so they're constantly hungry. Now, if we look at the opposite end of that when you're dieting, you're going through the same shit. Nothing ever touches the side. It's still that same system, but for a different reason. Now that you're low body fat, you don't have enough leptin, but you have good leptin sensitivity. On the fat person's side, you got plenty of leptin, but no leptin sensitivity. So you're hungry and a hostage at both extremes through the same system for two different reasons.

The coaches that I mentor on this very topic that I work with and try to get more psychological understanding of physiological responses, I have them read the Minnesota Starvation Experiment so they can understand that fundamental concept. Like being dick skin lean, your body is basically fighting every urge for you to keep getting leaner. Like, you will eat until your fucking gastric system explodes if you let it. That's why people have so many internal, like, they get so, so many internal disorders or problems, gastric issues. They end up having to like, I'm going to see a coach about my GI because it's so fucked. Post-comp, it is a fucking bottomless pit. And the funny part is, I'm not sure if you've seen this, but I have found for a lot of clients, even myself, the minute you start, it is, it cannot be stopped. It is like you have to be very introspectively aware to know like, I'm not eating to satiety here, I'm eating for enjoyment, but if I don't stop this, it will keep going. The system like, it's almost like the signaling just amplifies, gets worse and worse and worse, and then all of a sudden you're throwing up. But if you like, you have to be prepared for like, this is something I try to teach coaches to give their clients is psychologically preparing them for what happens post-comp. You're not going to satisfy that urge. It'll take months to re-regulate that systemization. Exactly as you're describing here, which I just cut off because I thought it was a great point, is that for that exact reason I have people try and read the Minnesota Starvation Experiment and then also try to get them to read The Gulag Archipelago. Try to have them understand starvation and starvation as a torture.

Yeah. That's the thing. You're basically, it's controlled starvation to get to the leanest levels. That's exactly what it is. And again, so anything at that level is not necessarily healthy, but we're not looking at health, we're looking at winning a competition. But it's wild. I'm that type of person where if I get a little bit of carbohydrate, I can't stop. If I get a little bit of taste of sugar, I can't stop. So the strategy I use with myself is I don't want to call it a cyclical keto, even though it becomes keto just because of the deficit and I am showing ketones. But I use a protein leverage diet like five or six days of the week where it's three times body weight in protein and as little energy as I can get in from carbs and fats. And then I refeed over the weekend. But in order to make that work, I have to have a massive deficit. Like I have to run on a 1500 calorie deficit or so every day in those five days because I have to bank calories because the minute I have a bagel or a slice of pizza, I eat two pizzas or I eat 12 bagels and I can't stop. So my refeeds over the weekend are like maybe 24 to 36 hours only because I can knock out 1500 grams of carbs in less than 12 hours because I can't stop myself.

Yep. And this is such an important factor again, this is why I think the lecture we're trying to bring out, not to make this podcast about that, but it's just so, it's something that I wish more coaches understood, which I'm glad you brought up, is the psychological response. So we cannot separate the psychosomatic relationship. People try to, they try to talk about like, just don't eat as much or just, you know, train harder or just do this thing.

Just do less heroin.

Yeah, if that If it worked like that, fantastic. We wouldn't have an obesity issue, we wouldn't have all these, we wouldn't have any of these concerns. We wouldn't have jobs. Basically, it'd be like, train harder, eat less. Cool, I don't need a coach. The fact is, the relationship between the brain and the body are so intertwined. It is systematic. It is so compartmentalized is the wrong word. It is a duality that has to exist. In order for the brain to exist, the body exists, the body exists, the brain exists. You can't have that separation. And so when we have these things where it's like a post-comp

binge and these coaches are just like, "I just don't eat." Or like, I've worked with that many girls where there's show day plus one to two and the coaches drop them. There is no post-comp protocol, post-comp pain, no being there in the corner.

No exit strategy.

But the scarier part is there's no preparation for that back off. Like, you trying to like, one of the things that I start to really push is as you get closer to show day, most of the work's done. We just need to guide you in now the refeed, loading protocol, see how you look, de-stress, declutter, let the body relax. It'll usually peak itself pretty well with those protocols. I need to make sure that you're mentally prepared for what happens afterwards. A lot of the time it goes show day plus one, see you later. And then it's like, well no one's told me about what the fuck left in the grellina, no one's told me about appetite regulation, no one's told me about hormone regulation, no one's told me about my anirhenia, no one's told me about any of these factors that go on in my body and now I'm left to binge and then all of a sudden it's bodybuilding's fault. That's not bodybuilding's fault, you're a shit coach. Yeah. And you weren't prepared for what is going to happen to your body. You, the second you start to get these food signals, the second you start to, especially when the goal is goal of show day and then you don't have a goal post-comp, you don't have process or performance goals outside of that, it's just objectively the outcome is show day, see you later. There is nothing psychologically stopping you from the binge, and there's everything driving you to the binge. And then we get these completely fucked lifestyles, the physique's blown out, body fat's gone again, so four weeks time I get that client from another coach or from someone else, I have to diet them back down after four weeks because they just binged non-stop, and any metabolic benefit they did have from being so lean is gone because they fucking ate shit for, you know, four straight weeks, and now they're back to being fatter than they were pre-com. And it's like, well, now I've got to diet you again after just doing six months of dieting. I've got to re-diet you because you just fucked it. And there's no mental preparation for that or physiological preparation for that, that people aren't comprehending as coaches. Your job isn't just show day plus stop. It is getting that person out of that show. It's no different than coaches that do off-season, reverse out of season for any team sport. You don't just go grand final, see you later. All right, what are we doing in the offseason to finish off the year? And then how do we start preparing for what the year is to come?

100%. And you see that even outside of the bodybuilding, just normal Gen Pop clients getting lean. Like they set a start date and they set an end date, and they get really lean and the leanest they've ever been, and then there's no lead out, there's no exit strategy. It's like, okay, we need to figure out what we're going to do after this. And they need to be told during this process, like this is people are going to hear this and think I'm a monster, but I had a client that she was 102 kilos and 5 foot 4. So she was she was girthy, right? And I was like, we started training, she was training me four days a week at the IOPC and we I started dieting her down and I just realized like just telling her to eat less food and giving her strategies to that wasn't going to work. So I put her on 900 calories, basically put her on a protein leverage 900 calorie diet for 13 months straight. And she was training like an animal. She dropped down to like 62, 62 kilos, something like that. And I wasn't going to keep her on it that long. And some people were listening to me going, "Oh, you can't put women on less than 1200." Of course you can. If her fucking, if her lean body mass is like 36 kilos, of course you can. I'm not gonna feed somebody for the other, the rest of the 102 kilograms of fat. But she was doing totally fine, totally fine. And as she's getting closer to 60, I'm like, all right, I have to start talking to her months in advance that we can't eat like this forever. We're gonna start adding fruit, carbs, other stuff. We gotta slowly bring you out of this. So I started that like 12 weeks in advance because I'm like, I want to bring you back up to say 15, 1600, see where we're at and try to see how much we can get away with the other direction before we have to pull it back down. But you have to start that psychological talk early, predict what's going to happen because you know what's going to happen, but they don't really understand. Say, okay, you're probably going to gain three kilos, three and a half. We're going to set that as our upper end, and if you hit that, we'll bring the calories a little bit back down and we'll start maintaining this 62 to 66 kilos or so. And it worked fantastically well. We got her up to like 16, 1800 calories and she maintained her weight. But a lot of coaches don't think to start early to let them know what they should expect when we stop the dieting process and we try to get them to some type of like baseline lifestyle position.