Chapter 7 · Rebuild Health and Fitness Podcast
Objective vs. Subjective Data in Coaching
February 14, 2022
So I've got a, like, objective. I watched a video of you talking about objective measurements and subjective measurements and the importance that we have to go objective first. Can you just explain a little bit about that? And then probably the difference is like training going to be different to nutrition because nutrition you want someone maybe feeling a certain way, maybe their stress marks coming down, so they may be somewhat subjective, but I guess if you're monitoring them, you can do it objectively as well.
Data freak.
Yeah, but this is what I'm interested in, yeah.
Yeah, okay, so--
And just like the hierarchy, if that makes sense.
Yeah, so if you-- we teach coaches to do a SOAP model, which is pretty-- that's what you typically do in a clinic with therapy or medical, so subjective, objective assessment, and then give your protocol. So if we can't-- we need objective data because the subjective data will lie to you. Because it's so emotional. It's emotional. It's your viewpoint of things. So if you're like, how much energy do you have?” “I don’t
have any energy. Okay, let's try to measure that. How are your moods? My moods are fine. Then you talk to the partner like, man, that guy's a cunt. You know, we'll lie to ourselves. How stressed? Stress is a big one, right? So it's like, okay, let's talk about your stress. I don't feel stressed. Okay, you work 80 hours a week, you're going through a divorce, you wrecked your car yesterday, your kid's smoking crack. Cool.
Sounds like a good time.
Yeah, so let's take your blood pressure, HRV, and heart rate, and then their heart rate's like 95 just sitting there, HRV's in the shitter, and their blood pressure's like 150 over 100. Like, okay, let's talk about your stress again. And we have people just, they break down crying. And then it's like, I hate my life, my bosses, I hate them, and this and that and whatever. It's like, okay, this is probably the wrong person to go and beast them out in the gym. So we need to dial it back, talk about stress management, and probably not a great time to be doing a super massive deficit. We've got other things we got to sort out first. So, you know, a lot of people just take objective data. You go to the doctor, the doctor's going to take your height, weight, blood pressure, all that, and then, okay, what's wrong with you? I don't feel good. Okay, cool. This is what your numbers say. But you need to weigh that subjective data because the way people feel about themselves and about the situation, you can't just neglect that. Because a lot of times you'll see a lot of red flags where we might have to have some talks on how to change your mindset. You know, because what we teach is kind of like, how do you go, how do you switch your identity? Because if you switch your identity, that has a trickle-down effect on everything else. So like, I can look at the environment, I can bring you into the best gym, bring you into a gym like this where you're around like-minded people, but you don't know how to lift weights. So the environment's not enough. So you need to teach some skills, which is where we all come in. So I'm going to teach you skills, I'm put you in environment, but you can't change the behavior. So you have to learn how do I change your behavior so you make more positive choices than negative choices. Your behaviors are dependent on your beliefs and your values. So what's your belief system, what's your values, how you feel about yourself and everything else? You got to talk about that, and that's ultimately going to be dictated by their identity. So if you have somebody who's always been overweight, parents are overweight, their siblings are overweight, it's my genetics, it's my destiny. Okay, we have to talk about a nature-nurture issue and we have to do a mindset. If you keep saying that type of stuff, your perception is your reality, you're always going to be that overweight person and why are you even here? So you have to start, you have to look forward. Where would you like to be in six months, 12 months, two years from now? I'd like to be fit and healthy. I'd like to be this weight. I'd like to be strong. Okay, you have to start thinking like that person now. You can't continue to live like this person because the audio and video doesn't match. If you believe you're this person, you're going to say, "Okay, what is this person doing to be healthy and to maintain this?" You got to do that right now, which means you got to get that you got to take that fat guy out of you, put in a box, and then bury it somewhere, and you got to be this jacked, lean, whatever you're looking for. You know, everybody's priorities are different. Whatever you want to be, you have to start acting like you're that person now or you're never going to get there.
It's really interesting. And we speak about it a little bit, but yeah, you're right, and it is hard for them to flick their identity. I've made a little I've made one mistake, if I can think about it in the past. I wouldn't say a mistake. There was a person that was quite overweight. They wanted to be They were an Olympic weightlifter. So I got it so much into their head. They're like, you know, you're not trying to be a Olympic weightlifter, you are an Olympic weightlifter. A Olympic weightlifter. But then she retired from Olympic weightlifting. And I was like, fuck.
Who is she now?
Yeah, she was like a little bit gone again and I'm like, right, now we have to try and redo those sort of things where I probably should have handled that situation better from the off.