Podcast archive Unofficial · Luke Leaman appearances
Menu
← Muscle Nerds: Nutrition, Fat Loss, Stress And How To Be Successful - Part 1

Chapter 5 · Rebuild Health and Fitness Podcast

Evidence-Based vs. Evidence-Informed Practice

February 14, 2022

That's the Muscle Nerds page. Yeah, that's it. So I just want to talk about a few things that I think will resonate with our audience. Confirms my biases too, which is an exceptionally nice thing to do. So obviously one of the latest ones was like, we don't have a weight loss problem, we have a weight maintenance problem. You know, why do you believe that struggling people are struggling to maintain their weight?

Oh man, I actually, part of our hypertension course, I wrote a lot of this stuff in on the nutrition. People are confused. People are confused. You have, earlier you said you're one of the most evidence-based guys that I know. I actually don't like that because when you look at the evidence-based crowd, they think evidence is only what you find in research.

No, I think I'd say evidence is in like, you know, you've been training since you're 8 years old. You've done all the fucking lifting and the bro science, whatever you want to call it, and then you've gone into literature, and now it's just trying to combine this stuff.

To me, that's how it should be. If you are some dweeb in a lab coat and you're testing a small population for a very small part of time and you're doing protocols that we would never actually prescribe to people, that's really poorly done research, but research is expensive and that's how it has to be done sometimes. You just have to draw conclusions. If you're in the lab like that and you don't have a lot of experience under the bar, you can't really say that that's evidence. But by the same token--

Calm down.

We're just on there.

But then on the converse side of that, you can't just be a meathead and have lots of time under the bar and then deny what they find in papers. You have to leverage. That's true evidence. And that's why I like Dr. Lauren Banach, PhD in Nutrition, Institute of Performance Nutrition. I've done their grad diploma for that, and it's fantastic. He goes, I'm not evidence-based, I'm evidence-informed. And what I like about him is not only is he doing research, it's not just in the lab. They're actually going out. He works with a lot of football teams in the UK. He's on the field measuring lactate, measuring blood sugar, you know, measuring everything. And so they're actually doing more practical research on athletes while they're doing athletic-y things. You know, that's a real word, athletic-y.

It is now. I was just going to say though, wasn't there a study done on GBC or GVT and you looked at it and it wasn't even correct?

It wasn't GVT?

Like it wasn't the correct structure of the And it's like, well, people are going to take that, read the abstract, be like, oh, so this is what German Body Comp does. Was it GVT?

Yeah, it was GVT.

GVT, yeah.

But the problem too is it's like, okay, they said, well, GVT isn't any more beneficial than just five sets of ten. Cool, now people go, "Ha ha, Charles Poliquin was wrong, blah, so they're like, GVT sucks." It's like, no, it's still a good method. But then when I looked, when I actually read the study, this is not GVT. The percentages are wrong, the exercise, the way it's written, the exercise selection, what they did, it was all wrong.

So they just went with the old 10 sets of 10 and

They didn't even do that. I mean, the percentages for GVT, you start at 60%. Yeah. And when you can hit 10 sets of 10, okay, now you raise it up 5 or 6% and you keep doing that until you can't hit 10 sets of 10. That's the way GVT is supposed to do. They were doing like 80, 85%, 83.5% or something like that. You can't do 83.5%. You can't. Yeah, you've got an ex-fiz degree, right? I was like sets of three maybe. I was like, that'd be nice. You can't lift 10 reps with 80 to 83% unless you're really fucking weak and you're a beginner.

Like an hour between sets maybe.

A 10-hour training session would be good to go. But that's some of the stuff, you know, people will, they almost look at this stuff as a religion now. And they tend to not, people just tend to be really, they don't like history. And I like history, especially physical culture history. And so, you know, I look at things as if we look at nutrition, nutritional science is not that old compared to other sciences. It's not old at all. Neither is exercise science. So there's a lot. We can't look at one paper and go, "Ha ha, I told you, blah blah blah." It's like, yeah, but there's going to be a paper in two years that says that's wrong. So we have to look at that, but we have to leverage what we find in the gym. And I find it really interesting that most of the stuff that guys were doing in the 60s and 70s, eating one gram per pound of protein, all that, the types of lifting they were doing, now the literature is catching up to that. So whereas before the RDA of protein 0.8, we know that's not even near enough, especially if you're training. Athletic, they said 1.2, then a few years later it's 1.4, 1.6, now it's looking like 1.5. And I read a paper two, two and a half years ago that said, look, you might as well just eat 2.2 because it's moving that direction and we found no negatives to even up to 4.4 grams per kilo. So you might as well eat 2.2 at least and then not have to worry about it. But if you say that, people go, no, no, it's 1.8. This paper said it. And you're like, you know what? Fuck off. Yeah. I'm

more jacked than you. Fuck off.

But people will just jump on the probability of such a small thing and they'll go, there's something in this, and that's where they create this headline. It's like, no, you're still wrong. Like, there's a lot of papers out there and a lot of them are garbage. So again, it's deciphering through how the study was done, who's done the study. Crazy. Oh, there's a lot of funding bias towards this one, but magically it goes that way.

People love looking at the abstract and making conclusions, and they don't think about how long it takes the body to adapt, especially for people who are more advanced. You can't do a three-week study with 12 people and say, "Well, yeah, stretching doesn't work." Well, stretching takes a lot longer than three weeks to work. Well, this method doesn't work. It does if it's done for a longer period of time, but no one's going to do that because who's going to fund it?

People also find what they're looking for. They'll just find confirm, and they'll find it in between lines. They'll find it by misinterpreting, like literally

Just cling into their own ideas.

And there's even some studies done though that show that if you try to challenge someone on their belief, all it does is solidifies their belief even further. So it's so difficult to have those conversations. That's why it's not worth getting into internet.

It's crazy though some people don't believe that they have biases and then that's the problem, right?

Like, no. We have biases.

Everybody has biases. The best thing you can do is just be aware that you might have a bias. So be willing to look at somebody else's view too and then weigh it against your own view. And I'm just absolutely It's absurd that people don't just try shit out. Like they just take things for face value or they hear someone talking about it and they don't fact check them, they don't look into the research, they don't try different things, they just keep doing what they've been told to do. And a lot of times it does work, but it works real slow. I'm not paid to get people slow progress. I'm paid to get people world-class progress, which means I can't just look at what the evidence-based crowd is doing because I can do it faster.

Yeah, yeah.

Because I'm not chained by evidence. Yeah. We're not peer-reviewed, on a piece of paper evidence.

Almost everything works, though. I think that's what people forget. Every training method works. Every diet works.

Every diet works, yeah.

It's just finding what's like, I don't know, works for you and what you're happy to stick with because that's another reason why people have no problem losing weight but they have a problem maintaining it is because they are doing stuff to lose weight that they're not going to do for the rest of their life. They'll usually get it to an end date and be like, "Yes, I did my 12 weeks!" Back to their normal habits that got them to where they were in the first place. Yeah. Well, that might not be, you know, everyone's results. They're doing it for different reasons.

It comes out of that bias thing. It's like if you're the type of person and you're the body type and you've got the biochemistry that works really good with carbs and low fat, you're going to be like, okay, everyone needs low carb or high carb and low fat. If you're on the opposite end, that's what you're going to preach, and people need to understand it. Every single person needs something slightly different, and they're going to need, they might need different things at different times. Like, I'm very much a low-carb dieter for myself, but my idea of low carb is a lot different because low carb is based on total energy and how much output you have and how much fat-free mass you have. So low carb for me is like 125 grams of carbs. Some people go, "That's not low enough." That's low for me. Because my maintenance carbs are like 350 to 400 when I'm not dieting. That is very low carb. And a lot of people, I guess because of the very low carb stuff and the keto, they don't understand that traditionally in the literature, low carb is 40% carbs or lower. So a zone-based diet that's 40-30-30 is actually technically considered low carb. If I tell you low carb, a lot of people go straight to Atkins and keto.

Yeah, nothing. As low as possible. Yeah. Yeah, and then keto is a strange one. Probably because people don't measure if they're in ketosis or not, they just say, "I am."

But they're still using the fucking pee strips and that doesn't tell you anything. You know? A lot of people are adverse to pain so they won't actually prick themselves and look at their BHBs and all that, right?