Podcast archive Unofficial · Luke Leaman appearances
Menu
← Misconceptions in Fitness: Strength and Exercise in Reality with The Muscle Nerds

Chapter 4 · Meant to Move

Context and Nuance in Fitness

June 24, 2025

I think you hit some really interesting and excellent paradoxes, which is what muddies the water here for so many people, which I think is super important to kind of cover. And a couple of episodes back, so I've had a little bit of theme over these last few episodes talking about programming and trying to understand how we get to where we are, how to progress. And, you know, I think for a lot of people, there's a lot of programs, like you said, you know, you had three different types of people doing maybe the same program and we can argue whether that program is good, bad or indifferent for that person. And there's arguments to, like, for and against both, you know what I mean? Doing something is better than nothing. Okay, yeah. When is doing something better than nothing? Like, what's your opinion on that?

That actually hits a good point I just noted down that I wanted to mention. We mentioned like muddied water, and I think the thing that makes that water clear is context, right? I've said this a few times. We were, we held a seminar in Ireland, I think it was in 2016, and we held it the weekend after Luke presented at a symposium in Ireland. And John Meadows also spoke at that symposium. And so John Meadows spoke, Luke spoke, a bunch of people spoke. And then when we held our seminar, someone came up to me and said, "What did you guys think about what John Meadows was saying? Because it's completely the opposite of what you guys were saying." And we were like, "Well, hold on a second. We're coming from different contexts. Like Luke is teaching this from the context of longevity, health, generalization. Meadows was speaking specifically on how to put on as much muscle mass as humanly possible. And so neither was right or wrong. They were contradicting, at surface level contradictory statements and, you know, stuff that they were teaching. But when you look at the context in which they were teaching it within, the waters become clear. I think that that might be something that we forget. We make broad, not we, but like a lot of people make broad sweeping statements thinking that that applies to everyone, but you've got to pull it back into the context in which you're speaking it about.

It's very similar to like if you watch American news media, which is the most manipulative media on the face of the planet. No matter what they're talking about, it's like they'll take a 10-second snippet that makes someone look so horrible, but if you actually watch the full five-minute video, you're like, "Wait a minute, they took that out of context." So it's like if I said something and John said something and you didn't hear the rest of the talk, they would go, well, you guys are saying two different things. I'm like, no, no, no, no. I'm talking about performance, health, longevity. He's talking about bodybuilding. Those are two completely different, even though exercise and training and strength training is all in that same area, we're having two different, you've come in at two different points of the conversation, so of course they're going to sound contradictory. It's like all the hypertrophy. Everybody is obsessed about hypertrophy right now. It's all they want to talk about. It's like, don't do back squats because they don't develop your legs for hypertrophy. They're not specific enough. You need to do leg extension and you need to do special exercise for your quads. Okay, I've never seen anybody that could squat 300 kilos and ate a lot that didn't grow massive fucking legs and huge glutes without having to do any hip thrusts or anything else. Okay, so the squat is not highly specific to any muscle type or any body part, but it is a good overall leg builder. To say you're not going to hypertrophy from that is ludicrous. Now, if we're having a if we're going to have a conversation about just the quads or just the hamstrings or just the glutes, now we have okay, now I'm going to agree with you. We have a completely different, the squat's probably not the best thing for each of those independently. It's probably better to isolate those things.

I actually think you touched on something there. You said, you know, like you and Meadows were saying completely different things, but if you heard the rest of the talk, you'd understand. I think your problem is that people can still hear the entire talk.

And take what they want.

And take what they want. And it's like their critical thinking is kind of going. I was listening to a podcast a couple days ago on like the future of AI and someone at the end of the podcast, it was like a round table. Someone asked, you know, what is your fear with it? And one of the guys answered and he said, it's getting hard enough for people to distinguish fact from fiction, especially in the even within their own industry or their own set of expertise. He said, you know, he made a really good comment about the difference between knowing

a fact and understanding what that fact means. And I think that the understanding, because knowing and understanding are two different things. We're seeing that now. We can throw around facts that we've heard a million times but not really truly understand what they actually mean. So yeah, I really liked that people can know a lot, but doesn't necessarily mean they understand a lot. So yeah, so there could be people that heard both talks and still listen to it through their bias or through the straw and just, yeah, it's getting messy.

No, I think it's great because this is what we started with when we first came in. It's about perspective. It is about perspective and it's about context. And we all come from, you know, in our health and fitness and wellness journey, we all come with our own set of biases and experiences that give you this set of beliefs when it comes to movement. And I think the beautiful thing about health and longevity and fitness and all of this kind of stuff, the beauty is the fact that there isn't one answer. Like that to me is the really cool thing. So for someone who doesn't want to do calisthenics and, you know, I say in quotation marks, weird movements like I like to do, oh my goodness, like go see you guys, you know what I mean? Like this, like I'm not, I'm not the person for you. I'm not the right coach for you and vice versa as well. And it's not to say that I would never learn anything from you, which is where I think the challenge and the problem lies is that when we're talking about something as general, because it really is as general as strength training, what I just wish that we could go into a conversation with you guys and be like, what did I really like about what they said about strength training? Not like, oh my God, they said this thing about strength training and that's wrong and that's blah.

Love that emotion though, right? There's a lot of people that have got, that just thrive off conflict.

People just want something to be mad about, you know, and our industry is no different. You know, here's the thing, like in the early start of my career, I had coaches that were just into the strength training, performance training, and they used to make fun of me because I got into It'll Portal, gymnastic bodies, gold medal bodies. I was doing the calisthenic stuff. I did a little bit of CrossFit for a time. I did my weightlifting, I did powerlifting, I did bodybuilding. They're like, you're never going to get good at anything. I'm like, look, I've been good enough at all the competitions I've done. I've won a lot of things. Then I got bored. I got ADHD. I got bored and I went to something else. But you know, it's going to pay off at some point because if somebody comes to me and wants handstand progressions and wants to solidify that, I know how to integrate strength training and I know handstand progressions. If somebody wants to do the splits, I can give them that while also giving them a triple body weight back squat. So it's like the problem is these biases that people have. They think that their way of training is the only way and it's the best way. If you're a powerlifter, you think everybody needs to powerlift. If you're a bodybuilder, everybody needs to bodybuild. I'm like, well, you don't have to, it doesn't have to be this or that. Why can't you do a lot of different stuff together? And that's okay. And for general population, that's probably the best way to train them is use powerlifting when it's appropriate. Use gymnastics when it's appropriate. When it's going to solve a problem, use what's going to solve the problem and stop trying to solve the problem with a sledgehammer, which is what people try to do.

Yeah.