Podcast archive Unofficial · Luke Leaman appearances
Menu
← Misconceptions in Fitness: Strength and Exercise in Reality with The Muscle Nerds

Chapter 3 · Meant to Move

Exercise vs. Training and Specificity

June 24, 2025

Yeah, there's two things that kind of come to mind with that off the back end of that is the first is you've got people who do what they believe to be resistance training, but it's just what you say that it's cardio with weights. Like you're just doing, you're not doing enough to elicit the adaptations you think you want from strength training. And then the second thing is the SED principle. So when it comes to strength training within that SED principle, which is specific adaptation to impose demand, where does strength training sit? Like what is that specific adaptation or the imposed demand to elicit that specific strength?

So in order to elicit an adaptation, you have to do a specific, highly specific stimulus to do that. So if we look at the realm of strength training, and now we also have to have the conversation of exercise versus training, because that's another one. People go, I go to the gym. What do you do? I exercise. Okay. But when I'm talking to a client, I'm like, we don't exercise, we train because you came to me, we asked for three goals. You gave me three highly specific goals. It's my job to create a program and structure to make a blueprint to get you there via like standardized protocols or whatever's going to work in the situation. So a lot, I think a lot of people get it wrong from the client perspective, but it's also the trainer perspective too. Because I know I've been at gyms and I've seen six people in a row with a coach doing the exact same workout, and they're all completely different. I remember being in Perth and I saw, I was training and I was just watching the trainers as you do, and the little old lady doing box jumps. She had to be like 800 years old. I'm like, she does not need to, what specific thing is she going to get out of a box jump that she needs when she leaves this gym? Nothing. Then there was a little old man who came and same thing. Then there was like probably a 120 kilo girl that walked in doing box jumps. I'm like, okay, I'm seeing a pattern here. You have no idea what you're doing and everybody just does the same shit whether it's good or bad or productive or not. And you know, so it gets the industry's really muddy place right now, and it has been for a while.

We were looking we were actually it was at a good life and we were waiting for one of our the girl we were staying with the lady we were staying with in Perth we were waiting for her to finish so we were there for long enough to see enough clients go through this one trainer just doing the same thing over and over. Which is why but then you have the same argument sorry you have this that you have the argument that you can make that especially with beginners something is better than nothing. And so at what point does it need to become specific?

But something's better than nothing unless it's dangerous.

Risk versus reward. Yeah.

Or, you know, the girl's going to blow a knee out.

Yeah. 100% agree, yeah. Because it's, I think when you have that conversation around specificity, it removes, some people might think, okay, well, I can't do

do this because it's not specific enough. But it's like, well, hold on, no. Like, you probably should just get out and do something. Don't, you know what I mean? They don't want to get lost in the weeds. Like, to start off. But the more advanced you get, the more specific you need.

Something's better than nothing until it's not.

Yeah.