Podcast archive Unofficial · Luke Leaman appearances
Menu
← LUKE LEAMAN: STUPID SHIT WE HAVE DONE AND ANAEROBIC TRAINING

Chapter 7 · Fitness Rebels Radio

Anaerobic vs. Aerobic Training

July 31, 2020

So we spoke about this before and how and not many people know how to switch from the aerobic. They do all that cardio, all their low intensity and blah blah blah, tempo runs and that, but how do you switch it from aerobic to now pushing into the anaerobic and real HIIT training?

Yeah. Well, I mean, one of the things, this is one of the things we talk about to our students about, everything's on a continuum. So if you think about, you know, your least intense versus high intense stuff, you look at like low intensity steady state cardio is going to be your lowest hanging fruit, the easiest thing for people to do, but you need a lot of volume because the intensity is really low, right? It needs to be done, you know, multiple times. I would even say if you want to get the most out of your aerobic training is to go every day and try to do at least 30 minutes. If not, I'll have some people do 90 minutes a day. I've had people do two hours a day if they've got time for it, because we're trying to force those adaptations really quick for the aerobic system. So then when we're moving them up that line, we think, well, we've got low-intense steady state, we've got moderate-intense steady state, but we can also do aerobic-style intervals and things like that. Now, if I'm going to push them into anaerobic-style sprinting, number one, have you built a sufficient aerobic base to then justify jumping into anaerobic training? Because if that anaerobic base isn't sufficient, your anaerobic training is doable, but it's not going to be maximized like if you had that aerobic base. So, and then you have to think, why are you doing sprints? Like if I'm going to do anaerobic work, I need a specific reason because for me, the aerobic is very generalized and we are aerobic animals, so we need that system to be optimized. You don't really need the anaerobic system optimized unless there's for a specific purpose. So if you're an athlete, yeah, you obviously, depending on your sport, you need that anaerobic side. For GenPop, do they even need to go there? Maybe not, but it is cool to be able to move them into that high performance anaerobic training, and that can be very good for being time, you know, the aerobic stuff can be time limited because people don't have enough of time. But if we do some more anaerobic stuff, well then they continue getting in high level shape with minimal time constraints to that. Because the anaerobic stuff, if you do it intense enough, you only need, say, you know, two or three small sessions a week, like even 20, 20, 30 minutes of actual work. But what we'll do is to get them to transition, we use transitioning protocols. So what I'll do is they'll start out on the aerobic side, and when we feel like they're sufficient with the aerobic foundation, then we'll move them into reverse Tabatas to give them their first taste of what does anaerobic training feel like. And I think the reverse Tabata is really easy for people because since it's only 10 seconds on, it's much more doable. So it is still an aerobic protocol, but there is some anaerobic elements in there. We start to transition them from reverse Tabata into Tabatas and then making sure that the Tabata they're doing is an actual real Tabata, not a 45-minute Tabata boot camp class.

Yeah, because as you said, just then, you have some anaerobic in it and aerobic in it because I think people get confused that you literally go, because I think the way people learn it is five seconds alactic, then you know five to ten seconds, and then 10 to 15, no 10 to 30 lactic acid, then you go to a rope. And I think people have to realize there's always, you're always playing with everything at the same time and not just systems which don't.

Yeah, they're always running, just some are running faster than others. So if I, and then also we, I don't like the old model of teaching it by time because that you need more context than that. If I jog for five seconds, that's not alactic. I have to be sprinting as hard as I can to make that truly it's not just time oriented, it's also intensity dictated as well. So, you know, we might take them into reverse Tabata and then start getting Tabata and we'll use something that they can actually do a real Tabata on, like an Echo bike, Echo bike, Assault bike, Airdyne, something like that. Or if they're

qualified, if their orthopedic profile is good and they can sprint and they don't have any injuries, then we might have them sprinting. But it needs to be something they can get sufficient intensity at to elicit the right adaptations.

And I think people have to realize as well with Tabata, it's something, or even HIIT training, it's not, as you said earlier, just doing squat jumps or doing burpees. It's something which is continuous movement, which is creating that kind of lactic acid and creating the lack of oxygen in that muscles.

Yeah, it has to be something continuous.

It has to be something

I like it to be nature, so it's either going to be like very fast running, prowler sprints, spin bike, echo bike. If you want to feel what a true tabata is, get on an echo bike, right? And then just slam that out and you'll be sick as shit the first time. And we'll start with like one round of that and then if you're doing pretty well, it'll be four minutes of the tabata and then you rest as much as you need. Usually people at first might need like six to eight minutes or more to stop dry heaving before they can do another one. And then once they get that down, I think the most I've ever given anyone is three in a session. And that usually takes a good 40 minutes because by the time they get their second and third, they're pretty screwed. But the squat jumps and the push-ups, there's not sufficient loading for it. And I would even say like a rower's probably not a good idea either because there's too much on that pull phase, there's too much recovery. You want to be able to go, go, go, go continuously. So that's why the air bikes work really well because they get the whole body into it. So then once we're done with that, you know, if you think a Tabata protocol done right is primarily aerobic, but there is about a 28% anaerobic gain from that too. So it makes a real good transition into then moving into anaerobic capacity and anaerobic power. So, you know, we might think when we start getting like true HIIT training, we're talking like 30 seconds to 60 seconds all out. And then I much prefer them to have a full recovery in between bouts because if I'm giving somebody anaerobic training, it's going to be for a specific performance reason. I don't give HIIT training to lose body fat. I do HIIT training to make them faster and so they can produce more power in that time domain. You know, if you need to produce power hard out for 30 seconds, then we're going to need a good, you know, probably three minutes of rest at least before you do it again. And then if it's sport specific, then you might want to look at the sport and say, well, they have a 30-second all-out effort, and then they only have about 40 or 50 seconds. So then we start restricting the time down and down and down. But then it goes, it quickly becomes anaerobic initially, but then becomes more aerobic over time. And you'll see that because their power will go down. So the wattage they're putting out will go down every single rep. But that's a great thing to measure because we're trying to eliminate how fast that drops because we're looking at power endurance.

I think that's the thing I think people get really confused with, is they think because they're going fast and hard for like, say, 30 seconds on, 30 seconds off or whatever, they call that high intensity or they call it kind of like HIIT training. It's like well no, you're actually doing aerobic training because you're not able to create the intensity to make it proper anaerobic work. And I think that's where people get really confused in the industry. They just think because you're going hard, like Tabata technically, the real Tabata is more aerobic than anything else.

Yeah, and the original Tabata I think was done on a Wingate bike too. So that'll tell you something. So but I think it'd be done really, really well done on an Echo bike, especially the Echo, because the Echo requires the most power production when you use it. It's got the biggest, most rigid fan on the market. So that's why it's the one used in the CrossFit Games. But I actually bought one for our facility here, and I bought it for me mainly. I told Zoe it was for the members, but I wanted it. And now I can't use it because everybody loves it. They get on it and they're like, "Oh my god, that was horrendous." And then I catch them every time I come in, all the members are using the bike. And I'm like, "This is fantastic," because I didn't think that the general population would fall in love with a piece of equipment that's the most sadistic piece of equipment on the market.

But yeah, it's been fantastic. But like you said, if you don't have complete rest, your power output's gonna go down. And the reason the power output goes down is you're no longer able to tap the anaerobic reserves. You're having to use aerobic stuff, which is a much slower energy process than anaerobic. So if you get on the Echo bike and you go 30 seconds hard out, you might pull 13, 1400 watts. And then if you only rest 30 seconds, you get back on the bike, well now you're at 1000 watts. If you rest 30 seconds, get back on the bike, now you're at 700,

30 seconds get on the bike, and you just see the power going down every single time because now that's primarily the aerobic system working, not the anaerobic. You know, so But it's, you know, it's a very confusing topic, right? So the way people are taught these energy systems, they're just it's like looking through it like a straw, like they're only seeing a small piece of it, and then they start making wild assumptions about things. And when you really get into and study it, you realize, oh shit like this is counterintuitive to what I thought I was taught because I wasn't taught all the everything I needed to know to use this and apply it correctly and understand it correctly.