Podcast archive Unofficial · Luke Leaman appearances
Menu
← 464/ Stop dieting like this! how much protein do you really need? could more be better? what you don't know about muscle, protein + body composition | luke leaman 2

Chapter 6 · 100% Real With Ruby; nutrition, strength, fat loss, muscle, macros - without the fluff

Managing Appetite and Chronic Dieting

February 27, 2026

Yeah, and because we're pretty much leading into the macros and micros part of it, before we dig further into macros and micros and the magic of protein and how sometimes more is better. There's also the fact that you and I both agree that percentages for macros are the stupidest thing ever because like you just said, you want to do grams per kilo because what's going to happen? Like as soon as you lose weight, you're going to drop your like it's just like it's stupid. But before we go into that, I want to clarify that when Luke was talking about anorectic hormones, that usually means the loss of appetite. So anything that is anorectic means you're going to be fuller/the hunger. So that would be, like you said, carbs with the insulin. But something that I feel is really important to talk about is the loss of appetite when you have been chronically dieting and how that isn't a good thing. Whereas a lot of people hold up a trophy like, "I don't have an appetite," and how that happens.

Yeah, I mean, look, in a lot of cases, if you are dieting and because there's a lot of different things that could be going on here, but look, if you're dieting and you're not hungry, something's wrong. You're probably not eating as little as you think you are. But you you could can have people that are really if they have a lot of energy on their body a lot of a lot of stored energy I've got to use the political term for fat these days but you have a lot of stored energy on your body. You know you may be hungry initially in a diet but quite often if you've got enough body fat once you start upregulating more fat oxidizing enzymes and especially if you layer on top of that getting in proper nutrition like you're getting

plenty of micronutrients, you're getting your essential fatty acids, maybe you're taking a multivitamin, multimineral. In a lot of cases, you can balance out that hunger because you're, I don't want to say it sounds so weird to say like on a cellular level, like on paper you might be in a deficit, but your body's making up that deficit with stored energy. So if you've equalized that, then you're losing weight, but you might not be hungry just for the fact that you're ripping off so much body fat so quickly that you just don't have the desire to be hungry. So that can happen. So you might go from this, you might have this transition period where you're hungry for a few weeks and then all of a sudden your body figures out how to balance out what that deficit on paper with what you're actually giving to the cells. And then when you get really lean again, or when you start getting really lean, then you'll start getting hungry again because you don't have as much fat to lose, right? So, but you can get people, depending on how their brains are wired, sometimes people are stress eaters, sometimes they're stress dieters or non-eaters. It's like I'm a stress non-eater. I could go all day, if I'm stressed out, I go all day without eating, and then I end up binging at the end of the night. So you see all these weird patterns with people. But I would say like if you're not hungry in a diet, you're probably not dropping weight, but that doesn't mean or body fat. That doesn't mean that's necessarily a bad thing because if you let's say your TDEE is 2,000 and you're eating 1,500 on paper, but maybe you're actually eating like 2,000. At least that's not the end of the world. Are you losing a lot of fat quickly? No, but at least you're building strength and muscle. And then as long as you're consistent, you can make your adjustments. Like look at what you're eating. Is there a possibility I'm overeating or I'm screwing up my measuring or whatever? But a lot of people, because I used to preach this, like people shouldn't chronically diet, blah, blah, blah. And then, you know, 10, 20 years later, I realized like the research on this is pretty good that people massively underreport what they eat. And a lot of cases, even coaches do it, but in a lot of cases they're doing it a lot of times because they don't realize, they don't understand it enough to be able to be consistent. Or again, like we go back to the labeling laws, they might be eating a lot of stuff out of boxes and just accidentally be over consuming energy and not even realizing it, you know? So there's a lot of things. But I would say if you've been chronically dieting and you're not losing, what you might consider doing is let's go ahead and slowly raise the calories back up and just see at what calories do you actually drop or actually start to gain weight. So if I give you like another 200 calories and you go for a couple of weeks and you'll have weight change, another 200 calories, another 200 calories, and all of a sudden you start consistently gaining weight, okay, at least now we know where we're over the line and now we can bring it back down again.

I want to highlight that like it's over two weeks because the acute change doesn't mean anything because you have food volume and then if you're increasing with carbs, there's also the glycogen and the water weight that goes with that. So you can't just rely on the scale and the poop.

And the poop. People don't think about that, right? So especially if you look at people who have been dieting, you have less bulk, you have less feces, you're going to get less motility in the guts. Your guts are going to slow down digestion a little bit. They're going to slow down pushing poo out. So in a lot of cases, you're going to have a transition period where you add more food, your brain has to go okay I actually have more food now I need to push this shit out. So you may have a jump but you want to if you jump it's okay just make sure you stabilize and then add a little bit more.

This is actually taking me back to when I first started with you three years ago. I was on like 16 or 1700 calories and as soon as we increased my calories to you jumped me up straight away to 2, 300 because I wouldn't be game enough to do the 25 you wanted me on. But my weight went up a kilo and I freaked the fuck out. And I remember that. But it's like it stayed there for a little bit, but my body was actually like I wasn't gaining any more than that one kilo on like 700 calories more, pretty much.