Podcast archive Unofficial · Luke Leaman appearances
Menu
← 464/ Stop dieting like this! how much protein do you really need? could more be better? what you don't know about muscle, protein + body composition | luke leaman 2

Chapter 11 · 100% Real With Ruby; nutrition, strength, fat loss, muscle, macros - without the fluff

Physiological Consequences of Extreme Dieting

February 27, 2026

Well, and the thing is, carbs aren't the problem, insulin's not the problem, fat's not the problem, cortisol is not the problem, adrenaline is not the problem. It's everything. And again, it's a matrix of shit that clients don't need to know about. They just need to understand like this. I always just tell them like it's complicated. It's complicated. I can explain it to you if you want, but I just need you to know what to do and be consistent at doing that. That's the most important thing. But it's like your body wants to stay at homeostasis. If you want to change one direction to the other, you have to make it imbalanced, but you can get to the point where you're teetering imbalanced too much. So like everything's situational, everything has you have to line a lot of context, right? So if I have someone who just wants to lose 20 kilos in eight weeks, we can do that. But the consequence is you're going to lose some muscle tissue, you're going to be miserable, you might develop a disordered eating pattern, your sleep's going to get disrupted, your libido is going to go to shit, your hormones are going to go to shit. If I have an athlete that's like a coach comes to me and says, my athlete, I want her to get, I want her to drop 15 kilos so she runs faster. I'm like, how fast do you want this? Because if I do this really fast, she's going to lose power output. So even though she weighs less, she's also going to be

slower. So we got to look at that and say we can't do extreme stuff to do this. We have to do it in a way that fits into the environment and the context and the situation that we're dealing with. You know, if you had somebody who was really overweight and they had to do something like let's say an astronaut. You got an astronaut. I'm just going to throw out the weirdest thing I can think of. You got an astronaut and NASA calls you and says, "Look, this person needs to lose 15 kilos, 20 kilos in six weeks. Can you do it?" Yes. At that point, the situation dictates that it has to be extreme because we've got a very narrow time limit and this guy's going being sent to Mars or whatever they're sent to Uranus, whatever. You know, at that point, like we can justify doing something extreme and we can justify the consequences. But for the rest of our clients, you can't. Like it doesn't make sense to go through these patterns of high and low and high and low, spinning your wheels, trying to do extreme things to make things run faster than they should be run.

Especially because the way that I see a lot of people doing it is that they think that you can build substantial amounts of muscle in a month or two months. So they go through a building phase for four weeks, maybe eight weeks. Oh, I'm getting a little fluffy. I need to go into a fat loss phase. And they don't actually build any substantial muscle mass. They just keep looking worse and worse year after year.