Podcast archive Unofficial · Luke Leaman appearances
Menu
← #4 - Luke Leaman

Chapter 15 · The Apollo Show

The Problem with Large Group Fitness

May 04, 2022

Yeah. That's, you know, that's been a big argument with me and the people at my gym is when we first started doing the group training, I was writing like very highly specific, and I say highly specific towards fat loss and muscle gain, and I was writing really good proper periodized programs. And then I kind of backed out of that and we were still doing that, but then we started adding in some huffy puffy work. So we started adding in some giant sets with some cardio stuff and they actually like that better. And so it's like, okay, what I know is going to work the best for them isn't exactly what they wanted to do. And from a business perspective, I'm like, okay, I'm going to write controlled F45-y type stuff, but safe because they enjoy that. So we might do a giant set and throw a sprint or a row at the end of it.

Mate, I love that shit.

What I hate is what you just said, like F45. I look at that, like I've been in a class before where I was looking around, I literally thought my head was going to explode because I just saw all these very unstable people doing jump lunges.

And you're just like, man, even I wouldn't do jump lunges, even though I've got injuries, but I'm very stable, but man.

Yeah, F45 is a funny one because you might have 40 people in a class and two coaches, like that you can't, you have to have a, if you're going to have that many people in a class, they all have to know how to train correctly and they have to know how to scale their exercises.

I used to own a gym and our gym was small group classes and we had 8 people per class as a maximum. And I guarantee you if I had close to 8 and there was someone who wasn't of the same level of everyone else, I felt like a shit fucking person because I would be spending all my time with the person who was novice, who didn't know what they were doing, even though they'd been onboarded. But it's just if you don't have the So if you've got 40 people in a class, it's near impossible to have them all doing the right thing, especially if they're dynamic, fast movements designed for cardio. Like having I don't know how these big companies don't get their bum sued off. Because honestly, like if you willingly let, you know, a 40 kilos overweight person who's never done any weight training in their life come and do a boot camp style jumping, you know, box jumping, whatever, and they blow an Achilles.

They should be able to sue you, even if they even though they signed that contract, they should be able to sue you. Like, that's bullshit. That's like professional ignorance, like just like just letting someone just whatever, you know.

100%. It's malpractice is what it is.

That's a great way to put it. Yeah, that's what I was looking for.

Yeah. But it's like if you look at you go to the park and you see people doing a boot camp.

Terrible idea for anyone who's not 18 with able-bodied joints.

Yeah, and I will say this, if they keep some of the exercises pretty low-level easy stuff, like push-ups, you're not likely to hurt yourself on a push-up. If you hurt yourself on a push-up, you probably should take up stamp collecting or something, crochet or something, I don't know, just don't even work out.

Just wear a bubble, live in a bubble. But when you go to F45, they did, they're having them doing box jumps under fatigue. They're having them do really terrible looking deadlifts. Then there's no foundational onboarding to get them to that point. You see that with a lot of the big group stuff and not enough coaches to pay attention.

And the annoying thing is that, well, there's two things, that there's not enough, like there's not enough good coaches anyway. So the likelihood that there's going to be two good coaches in that room of 40 is low anyway. And then you're going to do all this other stuff, so the risk is quite, it's a very high-risk exercise. But the other thing that's really annoying to me in the fitness industry is that the only way to lure people in, Fitness 45 is super successful, and that's because of the constant variation and that high risk reaps high reward. Like those people lose an incredible amount of weight very quickly and like they could do things a lot smarter, but if they did things smarter and only did low impact exercises for everyone, would they keep, you know, their audience? Maybe not. Maybe if they didn't, because they do like CrossFit style competitions against each other, they do F45 games, things like that. So, you know, it's a fitness has to be like, it would be good if people could be a little bit more open to things that are more structured.

Yeah, 100%.

And less having to, like, I need variety, I need to be engaged, I need to have, I need to be engaging in this like it's a fun game. You know what I mean? I wish people would just give that a time, that there's a time for that. Maybe do your, you know, a safe version of F45 once or twice a week, but it'd be nice if people also just said, okay, I'm going to calculate this like it's an actual, I'm putting data into a computer. People would see such a huge difference in their overall

overall results.

Yeah, I think a lot of it is that the basic foundational stuff isn't sexy enough to sell and it's not entertaining enough. And I was, so I'm training these two kids that are, they're 16, they're basketballers, super tall, and we're training and I told them, I said, look, I know this training's, I know this is boring to you guys right now. I know it is because it's not, you know, fancy, there's no shiny bells and whistles and shit, but this is what you need to do now to be able to get better at basketball. Like, that's period. You want to get stronger, you want to get a higher vertical, you have to lay the foundation with this boring ass shit. And if you're trying to get strong, training is not entertaining. It is very boring and it's very repetitive, especially at the beginner level where you have to have the law of repeated efforts. If you want to get really good at the squat, guess what? You're gonna have to squat one or two times a week for a very long time.

For like 40 minutes straight both times.

Before you need to do anything else. But people get really bored. And that's what we found too when I wrote, because I was writing GBC stuff and 6/12/25 and the clients would do two or three sessions and go, "Oh, this is boring." And I'm like, "Look, I need to explain to you what we're doing here. We're using strength training to get stronger and build muscle." They're like, "Well, I want to lose fat." I'm like, "Okay, that has to do with your diet. I don't want to talk about my diet."

Yeah. Welcome to the frustrating world of personal training, everyone.

And they're like, "I'll just run more. Can't we do more cardio stuff?" You're not going to pay me to watch you run on a fucking treadmill. Like, that's not You're paying me to teach you a very technical skill. So just I'm like, just trudge through this for a few months and tell me what happens. We had guys that were deadlifting 80 kilos, end of three months they're deadlifting 150. Now they fucking love lifting. They're like, holy shit.

Exactly. That's the great Well, you know what? That is our whole life, I feel like right now with being easily distracted, like, you know, I'm on my phone, I'm doing an email, oh, I get a Facebook notification, I go into that, oh I get an Instagram notification, go into that. It's given no one, everyone no sticking power to, they want instant gratification, they want to feel good now, they want to feel like they're doing the big weights now. And with cardio you can go really hard now, injury free. And most people try and go really hard now when it comes to weights and end up blowing their fucking ass out. You can't bring a cardio mindset to weights, but you will be severely rewarded if you do bring a mindset of learning and patience to your weights. You'll not only look the best you've ever looked, but you'll be feeling the best you've ever felt because you'll be strong as fuck. And you'll be feeling really good because you can actually see tangible numbers that are going up that you could never do at one point in your life. Whereas cardio stuff or cardio stuff, if you're doing actual cardio stuff where you're like, right, I'm aiming for a bigger two-kilometer row. I want to have a faster two-kilometer row. They are gratifying in a similar way. But if you're just doing like boot camp class and you weren't calculating how many push-ups you did, burpees you did, star jumps you did, how many runs you got through, it's fucking boring, guys.

Yeah, but look, I tell you, some I'm gonna get on that cardio thing too because I was about to bring it up and you got it. You nailed it right on the head with the cardio stuff. But a lot of people I find that are in the general population, they just want to come in and work up a sweat. And so what I would say to people like that is you don't need to pay to go to F45 to do that. You can easily get videos off of YouTube or buy someone's product and do it by yourself because, I hate to tell you this, but most of the time when you're in those big groups, you're massively already unsupervised. So there's no reason to pay a trainer when you're unsupervised when you could just do it by yourself, unsupervised, with somebody's $50 program.

Exactly right. It's a good point.

You do the same fucking thing, except you're probably going to get less hurt when you're not at F45.

Because you're not competing against 20 other people.

Exactly, and if you find a good coach like us or someone we know, they're going to write a program that makes sense, which means you're not going to sequence a bunch of exercises that don't pair nicely together.

Just remember it pays to not, it pays to pay, guys. So like if you, the thing is with personal trainers is that they're a dime a dozen, is that they're pumping out hundreds of them in a college every 12 to 16, what is it, 16 weeks now to get a personal training cert? And then you've got like 100 hours afterwards of like shadowing someone. So if you get someone who's only been in for a year, you're going to get someone who is, who was just like you 18 months ago. So like when you think of it that way, you're like, man, I don't want me training me. You want someone who actually knows what they're doing. And most people, unfortunately in my business, do it for the wrong reasons. They do it,

the personal trainers who have longevity are usually really good. The people who don't, who have just been doing it for two or three years because they didn't really know what to do, they're usually not that good and they're usually doing steroids. So they're usually not doing what they're preaching to do. So yeah, you want to be shopping around when you're looking for places to train because there are a lot of smoke and mirrors when it comes to the fitness industry. It's not all chicken, rice and vegetables.

Hugely. And most of the people that are getting it now don't have any time under the bar. They've never trained or they've trained very little, maybe a year, and they've said, "I want to do this for a career." And now you're training with somebody who's only been lifting 12 months longer than you have. So they have no idea what the fuck they're doing, and they're giving cookie cutter programs because they don't know enough functional anatomy, they don't know enough physiology or biology, they're giving nutritional advice and they're basically just copying and pasting stuff off, you know, bodybuilding.com. If you want to pay, pay for expertise. Don't just pay someone because you like them or you like the way they look. Make sure that they speak and when they talk it makes sense and then ask other people what they think. Ask other experts what they think about that person because, man, I've been in the education side of this for over a decade and there's a lot of Dunning-Kruger going on in our industry where people think they're smarter than they really are and they think that their knowledge is much deeper than it really is and there's not a lot of depth or breadth of knowledge in the industry, at least not what they need to know.