Chapter 8 · 100% Real With Ruby; nutrition, strength, fat loss, muscle, macros - without the fluff
TDEE, Deficits, and Strategic Programming
January 10, 2025
Yeah, so you look fast, slow. If we're talking about fat loss, we're talking mainly about larger or smaller deficits because that's going to be the main catalyst for losing weight. And that's the thing people don't want to hear. You know, I started going to gyms in the 80s, like when I was just a kid, and it's been the same thing in the 80s and the 90s and the 2000s that people don't want to diet. They would just rather exercise the weight off. And you have two viewpoints here, and I can argue both of them, and I'm going to tell you that they're both right, but it just depends on how you look at the situation. So if my TDEE is 3,200 calories a day, and that 3,200 calories is inclusive of my weight training. So we'll break down TDEE, right? You have your basic basal metabolic rate. So for me, it's about 1,900. Then you have about 20% added on for thermic effect and NEAT, non-exercise activity thermogenesis, right? Just kind of subconscious stuff that you do all day. And then if you look at that, that's only going to be like for a guy my size around 2200. If I don't exercise and my TDE is 2200, I'm going to have to diet. If I pull, say, 500 calories out, I'm going to have to diet on 1700. So, and you can lose weight like that. The only problem is, like you said, you're going to lose muscle. That's not a good way to lose muscle. How do we save muscle? You give muscle a reason to be around, which means you need to train a few days a week, at least minimal two to three days a week, if not four to five. But that's also going to alter my TDEE because if you're training for, say, three or four hours a week, that's going to add another 15, 20% to your TDEE. So let's say I'm going to train five days a week consistently for, say, an hour each of those sessions with weights. Now my TDEE is 3200. I have to shift that deficit. I'm no longer in a 500 calorie deficit if I'm still eating 1700. I'm now in a 1500 calorie deficit. So now that's going from like a small deficit to a massive deficit. But I'm doing the right things with the weights, but I'm just not feeding for it. So that's one side of it
it where it's like, all right, I have tried to feed for my TDEE without exercise, then I'm trying to use exercise to make a bigger deficit. But the problem is the more I do things, the more I have to drag those calories back up. Now you can look at it from a different perspective too, and you can say, well, I'm going to eat at my TDEE of 3200, and I'm going to use the workouts to create my deficit. But see, that's not right either because that 3,200 is inclusive of also the training. So if you're going to train your TDE is 3,200, that's your baseline. Now we have to pull calories from that. Now, in the first scenario where it's like, I'm going to eat a certain amount of calories, I'm going to train, we could possibly say you are using exercise to create the deficit because you've set your nutrition and then you've trained on top of that. Now, the other way is opposite. I'm going to use exercise or I'm going to use nutrition to be my deficit. So I've kind of set my nutrition and pulled back into a deficit, and I'm going to add the training. So in both of those situations, it's the same thing, right? So if I were to eat, let's say the TDE is 3200 and I go, I'm going to train for 3200 a week, and then I'm going to pull 500 calories out. You can look at that and go, well, you're getting that deficit through your nutrition. Okay. But I could also say, well, I'm going to eat 2700 calories, but I'm going to do enough work for it to be 3200. So in that situation, it looks the opposite. I'm actually using exercise to create the deficit. But if you think about it and you look at the math, they're both right. Right? Does that make sense? When you're programming, what I recommend people do is look at it from a perspective of what you're doing. If you are going to diet, I always tell people, for at least Gen Pop, you're better off doing less work and just eating a little bit less. And the reason is because it's easier to manage from time management. You won't make excuses of missing training sessions, and that's especially important if you're seeing somebody in person. So anytime you're doing fat loss, did I lose you?
I got you, but not your face.
Oh, there it is. You're back. So it's like, if you're focused on fat loss, set your diet and then train enough. Train enough to hold on to muscle tissue. Train enough to get the adaptations you're looking for. If you're trying to gain weight, we have a whole different conversation because at this point we need to feed up, not feed down. So in that situation, I would write out my training program and I would match nutrition. So fat loss, match your training to nutrition for weight gain, match your nutrition with your training. It realistically, semantically is the same thing, but it's a different way of looking at it. And what a lot of people will do is they'll try to write a training program for fat loss that has too much shit, and then they diet too hard on it. Whereas what they need to be doing is just doing enough to get where they need to go and letting diet do its work. And now if you were, if it was another coach, like people that I train, or if I'm talking about an athlete, we've got a different conversation because we've got some different things we have to take care of because a coach is wanting to get a lot stronger, like a lot stronger than what most gym pop want to do. They have performance things they're doing with, athletes have performance things, so we have a different conversation. But I think a lot of people need to look at the programming aspect of this and the application on the client side from what is the easiest thing for the client to do? What is the easiest? And the easiest thing would be a little bit less work, but also a little bit less calories instead of trying to feed up and train up, right? Because it's really easy for coaches, and I fell prey to this for a long time because I love to train. I don't mind like eating shit tons and just working like a madman. But the reality of most gen pop is they just don't have the time and they don't have the reserves to do a lot of this stuff. So we have to find strategies that work well for them.