Podcast archive Unofficial · Luke Leaman appearances
Menu
← 008- Breaking the Paradigm of Bodybuilding and Health with Luke Leaman

Chapter 8 · Muscle Intelligence — Longevity, Training & Human Performance with Ben Pakulski

Practical Nutrition Strategies for General Populations

February 21, 2019

So framing this around, I'd like to start maybe with what you would typically do for a client and how you kind of frame the decision-making process. But I'd also like to give the listener a takeaway, right? So not everyone can afford you or me as a nutritionist, right? So not even putting us in the same class. I know you're amazing at this stuff, but nobody can, not everyone can afford that. Not everyone makes it a priority. So if we had to give them some type of thought process on how to make that decision on their own, like, how do I start? Because I'd love to hear how you frame that.

I probably, you know, I'm going to assume, like, let's just like talk general population, right? I've probably the best piece of advice I've ever gotten on this is when we were all at Swiss a few months ago, I was talking to Andre Benoit. And Andre, ex-Canadian Olympic athlete, he was one of my mentors at Poliquin Group. He was one of Charles Poliquin's right-hand man. This guy is an amazing guy, knows training up and down. He knows nothing about nutrition. He'll tell you that. So I was asking him, what are you doing with your nutrition now? Do you outsource that or do you, you know, what do you He goes, you know what? He goes, what I found the best thing to do is just tell them to buy the South Beach Diet and just follow that. Because if you follow South Beach Diet for most general population, they're going to be pretty good.

I don't even know what that is.

The South Beach Diet is a modified Atkins Diet. So I think it was back in the late 90s, early 2000s, when everybody started doing Atkins ketogenic dieting again. There was a doctor from Miami, from South Beach, and he came out with a South Beach Diet. And it looks very similar to Atkins, where you do a 20-gram induction phase and you go to 50 grams, and you start, at some point, you start slowly adding more and more carbs to your tolerance, and you add in healthy carbs, and you start adding in more fruit, you start adding in a lot more plant matter, which is when you see people doing ketogenic diet, that's usually what they're missing. They don't eat enough plant foods, right? I think if people would just eat like a vegan and then garnish it with meat, that'd be pretty good.

That's the joke. I say I'm 50% vegan, 50% carnivore.

That's it, you know? Half your plate with plant matter and then one third of the plate of protein and one third of the plate of whatever starchy or fruit or whatever you can handle. Yeah, the more you train, keep adding in more carbs, right? I like what Charles Poliquin used to say, you got to earn your carbs. So if you're training really hard, you probably want to add more carbs in. If you're not training, you probably don't need that many, but you still want to get the phytonutrients, so you still want to add in lots of leafy greens, lots of non-starchy veggies, and then, yeah, you probably want to have a little bit of fruit because there's stuff in those, that plant matter you just simply can't get from anything else. The carnivore diet's driving me crazy, and I think it's going to have a massive backlash on people at some point.

Yeah, I mean, there's no doubt that long term that's not a good plan.

Short term could be a really good tool.

Right, right. So, you know, you look at Jordan Peterson's daughter, Michaela, like she needs this for her autoimmunity. It seems to make it way better. That makes a lot of sense to me.

You've got a pathological reason.

Someone who's obese, no problem. Restrict your food groups. You're going to get in shape, right? But then realizing that that's not a long-term solution. And people, you know, I've had people say to me, like, well, I cut that out for a long time and I put it back in and I don't feel good. Of course you don't. So like, that's what your body has, like just like you're speaking about. So slowly introduce it, realize that's a huge problem.

And realize that where you are now might be different after you lose 25 kilos of fat. You know, your body, physiologically speaking, will be completely different. And from a sports nutritionist perspective, it's my job to pre-frame this with my clients, say, "Hey, we're going to use this for a very limited amount of time, and this is why, but then we need to move to this over here. Because if you don't preframe that, let's say, and you hear it with every fad diet. I don't want to call these fad diets, but it is what it is.

It is, sure.

If somebody does a vegan diet, what do they say? Oh, I started a vegan diet and all my bloods look great and I had less inflammation. Well, you stopped eating Twinkies. Like, no shit.

Right. The problem is most of them don't, right? You're still vegan. Twinkies are still vegan.

But then you have people that do the carnivore diet and they go, "Oh, all my inflammation went away. I felt better." Well, no kidding. You cut out a ton of junk. You systemized what you were doing. But at some point, if you want to move forward, you're probably going to have to continuously tweak that. And everybody is going to probably move around the same place. If you look at most of the studies on low carb and high fat or high fat and low carb, if you look at these, I think I just said that the same. So when you look at these, I was thinking about this on the way over and I was thinking about the law of extremes. And I was trying to look it up on Google, like has anybody ever talked about this? And I couldn't find a name for it, so I'm just going to call it Leaman's law of extremes.

All right, I like it.

Whenever you go to the extreme, the attrition rate is going to be massive, right? So if you look at most studies that did extremely low carb,

extremely high carb, right? So in those instances, you have to give something up. So in one, you're going extremely low fat, one you're going extremely high fat. The attrition rate's around 60%, which means that 60% of the people could not sustain that diet. And most people will gravitate to around 30 to 40% carbs. Right? So and then before about 10 or so years ago, in the last 10 years it's changed a little bit. Most of the low carb dieting wasn't as low as people thought. It was mostly like a zone-based diet. Most of them was around 40% carbohydrates. So that would be considered a low-carb diet, even though that's not what we generally, in the general population, they don't think about that as a low-carb diet. But I think for most gen pops, somewhere around 25 to 40% from carbohydrates, you know, at least 1 gram per pound, 2.2 grams per kilo of protein is plenty for most people. If you're dieting really hard, I'd pump that up a lot, maybe 2.7 grams per kilo, and then, you know, fill in the rest with whatever else you need.

Now, is that, speaking to that, because I get that question a ton, is your belief that you pump that up according to, well, bringing one other macronutrient down, we're going to bring protein up, or is it a matter of like, hey, I'm training more, I need more recovery, I need these extra proteins?

You know, there's a lot of different things, like protein is really satiating. Why? Because insulin is a very satiating hormone. Protein is very insulinogenic. So you eat more protein, you tend to create a situation where you're not as hungry all the time. Then there's also, I like to, what I call caloric funnels, right? So let's say I'm eating 200 grams of protein and 300 grams of carbs, and I'm eating, say, maybe 80, 90 grams of fat. If I want to create a hypothetical caloric funnel, I don't necessarily need to take calories away. What I can do is parlay the thermic effect of food. So I can take 100 grams of carbs and switch that with 100 grams of protein, and now I've jacked up the thermic effect of food. Now that I'm eating 100 grams of carbohydrate, any carbs that I need up and over that, my body can make through gluconeogenesis, which is another caloric funnel because that's an expensive process for the body. Then if my body needs to make more fat because maybe I'm eating a little bit lower fat and not eating it, now I can create fat from carbohydrates, which is another energy costly process. So if I can trickle down hypothetical caloric funnels, then I can diet someone down but never take food away. Does that make sense?

Do you do the same with fat to carb? Obviously, carb is going to be more thermic than fat.

So if I have somebody on a lower carb, higher fat diet and maybe moderate protein, then when I'm starting to switch them in a modified low-carb diet, I can take some of that fat and parlay it into carbohydrates, and that increases the thermic effect 10 to 12%.

Same idea then what people are seeing with a carnivore diet. Even if you do an isocaloric, you know, say you did a 3,000 calorie carnivore diet compared to a balanced carnivore, or sorry, a balanced diet with, you know, 40% carbohydrate, theoretically they're going to have a greater thermic effect.

Absolutely. And not just the thermic effect, but then also the effect of changing some of that protein into what they need because there's certain things in the body that they need glucose. If you don't eat glucose, that's why we have gluconeogenesis, so you can feed things like your brain, like brain neurons and things like that, which cannot survive on solely ketones, right? Or then it can't survive off of protein or fat. They have to have carbohydrates. I think it's 60% carbohydrates, and they can run off 40% ketones.